homeresourcescase studiesOutranking Competitors 25x Their Size: How Compass Self Storage Dominates AI Search
Self Storage
28.1% Increase
in visibility across ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity
Top 3 Ranking
Moved from #6 to #3 recommended across AI sites
Company Snapshot
Compass Self Storage provides convenient, personalized storage solutions across the United States, offering personal and business storage, climate-controlled units, and vehicle storage options. As part of the Amsdell family of companies, which has decades of experience in the self-storage industry, Compass combines industry expertise with a focus on delivering a seamless customer experience through strategically located facilities and flexible storage solutions.
The Challenge: AI blind spots in a shrinking market
As high interest rates stifled moves and softened demand, hyper-local visibility became the top priority for Compass Self Storage. Because the industry lacks brand loyalty, customers typically choose whichever provider appears first in their search.
However, as customers pivoted to ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini with long, specific queries, Compass had no way to track if their brand was being surfaced. In this intensifying market, they were effectively flying blind in the new AI search landscape.
Their previous platform, Reputation.com, wasn’t built to scale AI search visibility. Their legacy architecture was designed for traditional SEO, so it struggled to scale the granular entity data and real-time sentiment signals required to influence AI search. Compass moved from a reactive "review-storage" system to Birdeye’s AI-native infrastructure that proactively structures brand data for high visibility in AI search.
“Up until last year, it was really Google that was the main focus. Now, with ChatGPT and Perplexity, there’s just a whole new ballgame starting — and we went, okay, how do we make sure we’re shifting with that?”
Katie Fete
Director of Marketing + PRThe Solution: Actionable AI insights without added headcount
Search AI provided Compass with a centralized dashboard to track visibility, accuracy, and sentiment across ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity. The platform delivered a prioritized roadmap of plain-language recommendations ranked by their potential impact. This clarity allowed the team to stop guessing which changes would move the needle and focus on the tasks that drove the most value.
The marketing team was able to act on these insights immediately, as most recommendations were executable without a developer. This agility allowed them to address overlooked opportunities, such as optimizing the mobile UX for the high-demand student storage segment. By flagging technical items like schema separately, the platform ensured the team could move at full speed without technical bottlenecks.
“It’s so actionable. With search, you’re often just trying things with no clear sense of what’ll move the needle. The ability to see a recommendation with its impact listed — that really caught our attention. We’re not playing that guessing game anymore.”
Katie Fete
Director of Marketing + PRThe Results: Outranking national operators. Built to scale AI search wins.
35.6% → 45.6%
AI location visibility
6.0 → 3.0
Average AI search rank
28.1%
Relative increase in AI responses
Key Takeaways
Key Takeaways
- Agility is now a deliberate strategy: Compass leverages Search AI to identify and act on ranked recommendations, allowing its lean team to optimize content quickly and efficiently.
- Early adoption creates a competitive advantage: By embracing AI-driven search visibility early, Compass is building a stronger presence before AI platforms become increasingly saturated.
- Compass is leading the new search landscape: Instead of reacting to changes in search behavior, the company is proactively establishing itself as a first mover in AI-powered discovery.
“Going from not having anything like this to having it at our fingertips is of tremendous value — especially as the usability of these tools only increases. It’s a huge benefit as a marketer.”
Katie Fete
Katie Fete, Director of Marketing + PR
Birdeye: The Obvious Choice
Recognized as G2's #1 Enterprise Agentic Marketing Platform across 10+ categories, Birdeye is the proven choice for the world's largest brands to consolidate their tech stack and scale local execution through AI agents.
910 reviews
38 reviews