Maggie McFly's® | Glastonbury

Sarah S. 

on Yelp

2 years ago

Stopped by last night and had a very attentive server. Parking lot was full at about 8:30 pm (on a Tuesday) and my dad had to wait for more to open up. Ordered a Margarita , tex-mex egg rolls and a Reuben and was very impressed will all three! I haven't been here since COVID times but would absolutely be back soon! I remember the service then being "meh" but it was so much better yesterday. Maybe a fluke because I see the ratings aren't *that* high but wanted to include my 2C. Glastonbury has *all* the food and I've tr... read more

Alicia N. 

on Yelp

2 years ago

Went to order a gluten-free free grilled cheese. Was about 5 min late. And I have order a gf lobster roll before and have been satisfied. I've order and eaten there and I've been happy however my to go order if a lobster grilled cheese just wasn't all that. It tasted good but the amount of lobster that they put and what you pay for isn't good. Would it have been different if I ate at the restaurant? It barely wasn't much on there .do I was not happy. There was plenty of cheese and the bread of course is delicious. It's like... read more

Jim L. 

on Yelp

2 years ago

We've eaten here three other times. I try to order something different each time from their huge menu. This time I ordered the Cuban sandwich. Let me preface by saying I grew up in Tampa where the Cuban was born (arguably). I know good Cubans. I miss a good Cuban. The Cuban I ordered from Maggie's was not good. At the foundation of all Cuban sandwiches is a flavorful roasted pork along with ham, Swiss cheese and pickles. I never found the ham and the roasted pork on this sandwich was the most over cooked dry atrocity I've ... read more

Danielle P. 

on Yelp

2 years ago

The menu is huge and a bit overwhelming, but in a good way. I feel like a large group of people can each find something they'd like to eat. I ordered a raspberry mint iced tea which was underwhelming. I couldn't taste any raspberry at all, so I feel it wasn't worth the price. My husband ordered the Back East Porter Chicken strips and fries which he said were good but could have been crispier. I ordered the Chinese Chicken salad which was very tasty , good sized, and apparently something newer to the menu. For desert we order... read more

Drew R. 

on Yelp

2 years ago

Big fan, local favorite! The new features to the menu are always delicious. The best appetizer is the spin art dip! 

Tami C. 

on Yelp

2 years ago

All right, all right, all right!! What a pleasant surprise to find Maggie's finally stepping it up today and joining the Glastonbury scene properly! We never had a good experience here, and it went from bad to worse over the long years. Against my past experiences, I agreed to meet my son & friends for a graduation brunch. The best thing going is the fabulous new staff. Shout out to dear young ALI --ALEXANDRIA who totally rocked our celebratory lunch. What a marvelous personality, a great asset to a once lackluster establi... read more

M M. 

on Yelp

2 years ago

Alexandria was our server tonight and was fantastic. We all had nut allergies and she handled them graciously and carefully. Her attentiveness to our needs made our dinner so much more enjoyable. And the food was delicious. We will be back. 

Lisa C. 

on Yelp

2 years ago

Our server Ali (Alexandria) was amazing and Super helpful with all our requests. Food was great (Pot Roast). We sat outside and enjoyed the ambience and fresh air. 

Nathalie P. 

on Yelp

2 years ago

Tayler was awesome!! So attentive, gave us an awesome recommendation on food and drinks! The vibes here are awesome! Perfect spot for a girls night or date! Highly recommend, worth every penny! I've never had food come out so fast and fresh! So happy i found this place!