Stone Creek Dining Company - Noblesville

Dave 

on OpenTable

12 years ago

We had to wait with reservation 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

I usually don't leave comments but for the money we spent at this restaurant I felt the need. My husband and I had been here many times. We had in the past enjoyed the food and atmosphere (although pricey) and wanted to go back for our anniversary. We had a table near the kitchen which meant a lot of traffic. Our water was warm and we were never given any ice. It took almost 20 mins to get our drinks from the bar. (This was a Thursday evening at 6pm) The waiter was just back from a smoke break and I could not stand the smell... read more

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

Mothers are special. So your Mother's Day brunch should be as well. This was not. Only offered their regular dinner menu, had a few breakfast offerings (nothing truly suitable for children). They didn't even print a special Mother's Day menu with the breakfast offerings. No toast, no pancakes, no scrambled eggs, no bacon. We had calamari for an appetizer at 10:00am. Staff wasn't prepared for this, table service was adequate at best. We saw several people arrive and then leave once they realized the menu was the dinner menu. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

The hostess staff was rude. In fact, there has not been a time I have been to this Stone Creek where the host staff was anything but rude. They appeared to be annoyed that they had to work and it wasn't even busy. On the reservation, we asked for a FULL booth, hostess said none were available, when we were seated we passed 3 booths that were available and 2 half booths that just needed wiped off. They sat us at a round table with 4 chairs. Server was ok, however, he kept telling us he would get with us whenever he could? Onl... read more

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

Applewood salmon was not very good. Sauce was overpowering and tasted like vinegar. Seafood boil was very salty. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

Requested booth for family dining event but they indicated they had none left yet when we walked back after checking in for our reservation we passed three open booths - very disappointing - the noise level is such in the space that you cannot even hear someone next to you talk - the fodd is very good and servered quickly 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

Stone Creek was one of my favorites and a spot I looked forward to going to until my last two visits. Service was really bad in November. This visit, service was not the problem, but the food was. I ordered the grouper "special" that was $30. It came out so salty that I couldn't even eat it. By the time they replaced it, I was no longer hungry, and had to box it as the rest of our table had finished eating and needed to leave. They didn't even offer to take it off the bill. I'm really disappointed, but the last two visits ar... read more

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

I wanted to take my daughter somewhere nice for New Years Eve dinner. Atmosphere and service was good. Food was not. The filet I had had quite a bit of fatty tendons running throughout. Baked potatoes needed to bee sent back because they were cool to the touch and looked as if they had been sitting for several hours waiting to be used. Fresh vegetables looked and tasted as if they had been cooked, sat around, were over-microwaved, and then sat again until they were luke warm prior to serving. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

I had the smothered chicken and it was so tough I had to ask for a steak knife! Also it was very loud in the bar area. If given the choice we would have never wanted to sit in the bar. Also our wait or was funny and amazingly attentive to our needs.