Brooklyn Diner

JerseyGirls 

on OpenTable

4 years ago

Was very glad to a reservation after seeing a show - just a short walk from the Shubert. We each had the house specialty- chicken pot pie. They are huge but we were both able to finish it. That with a glass of wine was perfect. Upbeat atmosphere. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

4 years ago

We met a friend we hadn’t seen for several years. Our waiter was so understanding as we caught up with our friend. The service was wonderful! Always love our visits! 

BethG 

on OpenTable

4 years ago

Our food was extraordinary. My husband and I both had the chicken pot pie and it was the best we have ever had. My friend had salmon and it was cooked to perfection, as good as any fine restaurant. It was directly across the street from the theater we were going to, so convenient. Yes, it was definitely a diner and as a result, noisy, and a diner atmosphere, but it was to be expected. Just fun. Service was great and so was the chocolate cake. 

sjvdo 

on OpenTable

4 years ago

Great experience! I would gladly return to dine here 

Loki 

on OpenTable

4 years ago

Food and service were excellent and were were there three separate times. The Manager was exceptionally personable and accommodating. 

jam4 

on OpenTable

4 years ago

Great after-theater casual meal. 

Silvia 

on OpenTable

4 years ago

Very disappointing. I was expecting more NY diner food like the W57th Brooklyn Diner used to have. Matzoh Ball soup was terrific but the rest of the menu mediocre. 

ScottG 

on OpenTable

4 years ago

Nice spot for a quick, informal meal before the theater. 

TVLG123 

on OpenTable

4 years ago

Super cute! Yummy food, great location! Our waitress was phenomenal and the manager was super nice! Excellent breakfast, we would definitely go again!