Carleton Realty - Westerville, OH

Noah D. 

on Birdeye

2 years ago

As a first-time buyer, and as someone who is naturally cautious about big decisions, I had a lot of anxiety about starting the home-buying process in an extremely competitive sellers’ market. However, working with Cathy helped me to develop the confidence to go from being a very nervous renter to a confident homeowner. Cathy took the time to get to know me as a person, as well as what I needed and wanted from a home. She thoroughly and patiently explained the process to me (more than once!), and answered all of my question... read more

Cody W. 

on Birdeye

2 years ago

Crystal Williams was amazing without her our family wouldn’t have been able to get the house we wanted. She went above and beyond, is a great person and without a doubt a phenomenal realtor. Without her this deal wouldn’t have been possible. We are forever grateful! 

Blair H. 

on Birdeye

2 years ago

The follow up, organization, and personal connection provided by our agent, Allie, was the reason we won the his on our house! We weren’t the top offer but the professionalism used during the buying (and selling) of our home got us our dream home in this crazy market. 

Carsten W. 

on Birdeye

2 years ago

Brett and Karla were fantastic. Couldn’t recommend them more to anyone. Incredibly responsive/friendly/professional. They are excellent at giving you all the information you need and gave excellent advice to us when we asked them for it. 5/5 stars 

Matthew S. 

on Birdeye

2 years ago

Our experience with Carleton Realty was amazing!!! Brett and Karla Hatley are superstars!  They are beyond pleasant and fun to work with, and they were there for us anytime we needed them.  They are overall on top of their game be it communication, setting up viewings, explaining what's good and not good to see in a house. We were first time buyers and they did such a wonderful job of explaining everything to us.  They make it very apparent that they are in your corner!  Honestly, they're so wonderful we feel that only a rev... read more

Amanda D. 

on Birdeye

2 years ago

I can't say enough great things about Carleton Realty and our amazing realtor, Crystal Whiteman! As first time buyers, my husband and I chose quite a tough time to decide to buy a house. But we were in desperate need of space with a new baby, a dog, and both of us working from home this past year! We hit the ground running with Crystal! She was so thorough when walking us through the home buying process, and quick to answer our MANY questions. She scheduled house showings promptly, which was necessary considering houses are ... read more

Robert C. 

on Birdeye

2 years ago

My wife and I recently relocated back to Central Ohio from Texas. We contacted Theresa Meyers with Carleton Realty to inquire about some acreage she had listed as we were looking to build. Unfortunately, the acreage had sold. Theresa expressed a genuine interest in our desire to build and we quickly began to develop a relationship. Theresa was very professional as well as personal in her efforts on our behalf. She routinely sent us leads from various counties throughout Central Ohio. Theresa showed her versatility when... read more

Joann S. 

on Birdeye

2 years ago

Allison Wolford is wonderful to work with! She is professional, knowledgeable, and friendly. Makes the whole experience great! 

Jacob & Renee H. 

on Birdeye

2 years ago

Beth Williamson was fantastic. In an insanely aggressive market where houses were going VERY fast she kept her eye out for ones we would like, made appointments for us as soon as they became available, and took us to viewings usually on that same day. Over a few weeks, we reviewed dozens of houses virtually with her, made 6 in-person visits together, and ended up deciding to bid on only one. With her coaching, we made a precise, targeted bid that we were comfortable with, and that was within the same price range as the nearl... read more