Brooklyn Diner

Momcat 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

This is our second time eating at the Brooklyn Diner. The first was at the Carnegie Hall location. Wonderful once again. Food was yummy, our waitress was a tad slow in responding, but the food service was timely. My lobster roll was delish! Different than a New England style, but I love how they prepare it. Would definitely eat here a third time. 

AnnetteM 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

This was a perfect choice for lunch before a Saturday matinee play with my 7 year old godchild. The diner is around the corner from the theater and an easy walk from Grand Central Station. The service was outstanding from beginning to end. We were immediately seated by our host and our waiter was prompt and friendly. He also pointed out a great choice for my godchild -- which she loved. I was also very pleased with my open-faced Reuben and the delicious cold slaw that accompanied it. The restaurant was packed, so having the ... read more

LynnS 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Our out-of-town visitors loved it: everything NYC has to offer- great food, great service, great location, great prices. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Third time and each time never disappointed. Great food, very confortable and you never feel like you are being "ripped off" I would recommend the Brooklyn Diner Time Square to anyone visiting New York. A great "find" 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

The food was great and the portions were huge!! However, the price was high, but the amount of food makes up for it. We had to change our reservation and they were more than accomodating!! I love this place!! 

noname 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Convenient for theater, esp. Town Hall. Portions are huge so plan accordingly. 

SheriS 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Not your regular diner. While the portions are fairly large where were the egg?. What diner doesn't serve breakfast 24/7 - that's the point of a diner I had a hard time finding something that appealed to me on the menu and ended up with the pulled BBQ chicken sandwich and my husband had a vegetable and hummus plate. Food was ok, nothing special. Certainly won;t go back there as just a so so place to eat 

JCohn25 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

I have been to both the one in the 50s and this one in Times Square, and this one is a lot less cramped, which gave a much better feel to the place. The food was good, but I think everything was a bit pricey. Granted, they give you large portions for your money, but most salads and sandwiches are $20, which is a bit steep. 

KennethT 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Food was just "ok".....prices extremely high for the quality of food received.