Brooklyn Diner

bronxboy559 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

I understand this is in prime real estate (off Times Square), but lack of kids menu and exhorbitant high prices ($19 for a hot dog, although it was enormous) made the experience very disappointing. Waiter was not very friendly. We were told that the corned beef and pastrami were not available that evening. That's ridiculous for a diner restaurant in New York, especially one that claims it has Brooklyn eats. Had the pot roast and kugel; very tasty but portion was extremely small for the $20 price tag. Didn't even come with a ... read more

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Two of dishes had to be sent back because they were cold - not just room temperature, but refrigerator cold. The soup was cold. The wrong bread was used on the sandwiches. I had chicken with bacon, gorgonzola cheese and bacon. The bacon was partially cooked; had the slightest bit of russian dressing on bread was dry and the sandwich was beyond cold. I did not like my sandwich. The best part of the meal was the waitress who went out of her way to apologize and correct and replace 2 out of 3 food orders. I believe a manager sh... read more

sb18 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

i have been going to Brooklyn Diner on 57th street for years and have never been disappointed. This is my second and last visit to Times Square Branch. On Sunday afternoon the restaurant was out of corned beef and pastrami - so no Reuben sandwich. I would have considered the Lobster Roll expensive even if it had been abundant and delicious. As it was, the portion of lobster was small, underdressed, on a dried out roll. Very disappointing. The waitress, however, somewhat redeemed the experience by her sunny attitude and atten... read more

MaryAnn 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Pricey - was $180 dollars for breakfast for my husband and I and three daughters. Food was good not over the top. 

gail 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

we were all disappointed with our meals rye bread on corn beef was soggy and way too much meat mac and cheese for children was so different not any of our 3 granddaughters ate it food was expensive and not that good will not go back 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

We thought the food was way overpriced for its taste and what you got. $19.00 for a hamburger was just too much to pay. We waited a very long time for our food as well. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Used to be a staple choice, not anymore. Cheapened the 18 Vegetable Salad to an unappealing overpriced mess. 

Joan 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

no omelettes after 11:30. and they call themselves a diner. overrated and overpriced. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

We booked a table for 11:30 on a Sunday morning and were not able to order breakfast or brunch. Who stops serving breakfast at 11:30 on Sunday mornings?