Brooklyn Diner

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

Unfortunately our experience was very poor. We were able to get a table for 8 people on a recent Sunday morning. But the service was extremely poor and the food did not come out as we ordered. The waitress was inattentive and slow. The special requests or additions were not filled. We don't mind paying for quality but as far as the service and food the price for this breakfast was totally unreasonable! We will not be returning. 

Jeffc 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

We booked Brooklyn Diner for a table in 10 minutes, rushing two blocks to arrive on time. The host said, "There'll be about a 20 minute wait." "Even with a reservation?" I asked. "Well, you just booked it 5 minutes ago." Indeed, and the Brooklyn Diner accepted our reservation. We turned on our heels and departed, since we knew we could (and did) get a table at the Red Flame right around the corner. If participating in Open Table, then honor the commitment. If something comes up, just say, "Oh, I'm sorry, your reservation pop... read more

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

I've been here in the past and had decent lunches, mostly for work. I took my family here on a Sunday around 11:30 prior to a show in Times Square. The food was average, the service slow, they were no longer serving breakfast during the middle of Sunday brunch time. My wife had a vegetable pizza which was soggy. And worst is that lunch for 2 adults and 2 kids cost $130!! Don't foresee going back. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

Very overpriced. Asked for no onions on salad. Seems like they gave me extra onions. Server did not seem to care. Chicken on salad was like sawdust. Son had turkey with mashed potatoes and gravy. Turkey was completly dried out and gravy tasted like it had a cup of salt in it. Just hurts more when it is so expensive for terrible food. 

EricF 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

Extremely overpriced for the barely better than diner food. I grew up in Brooklyn and this diner bares little to no resemblance to a real Brooklyn Diner. I realize it is geared to tourists, and priced accordingly, but as a New Yorker and a Brooklynite, I felt like I was mugged when I received the bill. No wonder they don't post their prices on the menus on their website or on the windows outside, no one would eat there. Dinner for 4, incl tax and tip, $175.00!!! And we only had 2 drinks and one dessert. Maybe it's worth if f... read more

LloydL 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

Went here for brunch at 11:30 on a Saturday before a matinee and was told they had stopped serving breakfast at 11:15. Which left our group of 6 with a very over-priced lunch menu to choose from. Service was a bit schizo - at times it was friendly and attentive; other times we got the feeling that having to serve our table was a bit of an inconvenience for our waiter (and we had no special orders or requests). Having said that, the food was good - nothing special but certainly good - and it's a good pre-theater location so I... read more

lilstyx 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

The food was ok. The service was poor, I ordered a salad and he waited until I ate my whole salad before ordering the dinner, which I never asked him to hold off. Also, it took over 1/2 hour to than get a burger. 

missestheolddays 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

usually the food is very good, but this day I ordered their Chicken Soup and it was so salty that I could not eat it. I must say, they were very understanding, and did not charge me for it, after I complained to the waiter, so I will continue to go there, and just not order the soup again. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

compaied to Lindys where is normaly go the menu us limited and $$$. The waiter brought our appiracitize and main coruse out at the same time. Problably will not return