Brooklyn Diner

PickyNewYorker 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Good place for the neighborhood-I met a friend for brunch and although the price was a bit high (considering no alcohol was included), the food was good, the coffee excellent. The people at reception were superb, but the table service was very slow. It took quite awhile for the orders to be taken. Happily, not rushed over brunch once served. 

JohnG 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Excellent food and service (we had breakfast) although quite expensive 

MaryM 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

We had a great time and enjoyed the food, especially the cheesecake. 

metoo 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

We always go to the Brooklyn Diner when we are in the City. My wife Loves the Pecan butter for her pancakes. NOT THIS TIME> it felt like they sold to new owners or have new chefs. Even the servers had a different attitude while interacting with the customers. Usually very friendly and attentive but no more talk more to themselves. Service was also very slow and when the food did arrive my wife did not get the PECAN BUTTER she had ordered. She Asked again. Then a few minutes later the same Waiter who took her order came and t... read more

WayneLady 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

First of all, in no way did this place feel like a diner, particularly one named for Brooklyn. Next, It had a tiny choice of dinner entrees and, incredibly, it was out of the 2 pastrami offerings, the most iconic of diner foods in the New York area. I will admit the eggplant Parmesan was very good, but for the price, it was skimpy, especially because the only side was an all-lettuce ( I swear!!) salad. Disappointing. 

LisaP 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

We dine at Brooklyn Diner every time we are in the city. Service is always impeccable. Food is delicious. Staff is charming Can’t wait until next time 

LizmaryM 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

We were a bit disappointed in our breakfast. One of our meals was cold, the bagel was hard as a rock and the polenta bites were not good. Even the coffee was a bit bitter and unappetizing...Our server was great though! We won’t be visiting again. 

BrookeA 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Great place to get a meal pre/post show. Kid friendly menu plus gluten free options. 

FDinLN 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

A convenient place to grab a hearty meal in the Times Square area. Had great service, a good, generously sized burger prepared to order, a bit lackluster fries (not super crispy), a very nice glass of Malbec, and steaming hot coffee. The cookies displayed on the counter looked large and tasty but, alas, I was full. The prices are Ok by NY standards, and there are counter and table options. I’d go back and try a regular entree next time.