Brooklyn Diner

Broadway 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Great as usual 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Last night was a miss. I’ve eaten here many, many times, but cold chicken soup is not ok. 

ConorD 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

This place is just fantastic. We found this on our first day of our NY trip. We have been to NY five times now and always enjoy a diner. We often find a different diner to go to every day as we often find the quality is comparable. This place however is a cut above the rest. We really enjoyed the atmosphere, layout, speed of service, and most of all the quality of food was just superb. We came here every single day and got looked after like Kings. A special mention to the Manager, Chris. You know what you did Chris. You made... read more

LIMike 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

My wife and I have been wanting to try the Brooklyn Diner for some time now and finally got the chance yesterday after the Columbus Day parade. The food was ok (my wife had the chili dog, which was lacking a decent amount of chili) and I had the chicken pot pie (which was huge but could have had more flavor) but the service was lacking. After we were seated, it took us about 10 minutes to get water and for a manager to come over and take our order. Service throughout the meal was slow, we waited some time, even between glass... read more

ToddG 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Although the food was acceptable, there was nothing terribly special about it. I got the double burger, and received two small patties that looked like pre-made, frozen patties. $19 for that and a handful of small fries (none greater than two inches long). My daughter got the $24 mac & cheese with frankfurters - a plate of mac with 12 thin slices on hot dog on it. Service was just all right - attention right up until the food arrived, and then, nothing. With so many other options, there's no reason to visit here twice. 

DinahLee 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Love, love, love the crispy polenta squares that are served with the Eggs Benedict dishes. However, still really miss the classic style with Canadian bacon. And, this time the eggs were a but under done and the hollandaise was too sparingly applied. Not their best effort. 

Tweety 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Great service there for an early Saturday breakfast 

deethridge 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

One of my favorite places to eat in NYC! The food is always delicious and the service is outstanding. They are always ready for you when you walk in the door and you are quickly seated. 

DonnaS 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Truly a gem! Wonderful food, wait staff and decor!