Maggie McFly's | Southbury

Debora S. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

My family and I went to Maggie's in Southbury for a little gathering to celebrate our nieces second child. Our sever was Jeice. We were a party of 19 with 3children. Jeice could not have been any better than he was. We asked for seperate checks for each family group, and of course all ordered our own meals. Jeice got every order Correct, every drink order correct and our checks were accurate. He was kind and attentive, we even embarrassed him by clapping for him. He did an amazing job and hope he is acknowledged. We know its... read more

Dana M. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

Dinner was delicious tonight. We love coming here with our family, there is something for everyone of us to eat. Evan was our server and he is such a nice young man. Very attentive and so patient. Thank you for making our dining experience 5 star. We ate everything so there are no pictures. 

Wendy G. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

The wings were out of this world. Very unexpected but a great find. They are crispy, meaty, and juicy! You can get them plain with a side of Buffalo sauce or immersed in the sauce. The Philly cheesesteak rolls were yummy as well. A good bar/comfort food kind of place! 

Jino T. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

We came here just an hour before closing. We liked the food we ordered, pasta and salmon. Ambience is good for who drinks as well as for family 

Joseph F. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

David Lee Roth sang Somebody get me a doctor! Portions of epic proportions. The fajitas were outstanding Lalo Salamanca could have not made them better. Always consistently great. Kobie was on top of everything! Right on! 

CC C. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

We came here for a very late dinner since everywhere in the area was closed after 9pm. A couple of the reviews made us hesitant but we're so glad we stopped by! I ordered the walnut chicken salad and it was delicious and huge. My hubby ordered a "custom made" vegetable fajita. It was fantastic and one of the best we've ever had. Lots of vegetables and very little oil. Our server was Ashley and she took great care of us and we'll definitely request her the next time. 

Jim C. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

5/10/22 I've dined at a couple of Maggie McFly's Restaurants over the years and they are consistently........well, consistent. A perhaps overly large menu might be what keeps them mediocre instead of really good. Sometimes doing a smaller menu well is better than a large menu ho-hum. This visit my buddy had a beefsteak grinder with Au jus & fries that he said were "pretty good" I started with a cup of chicken rice soup that was "ok"....nothing special I ordered an off menu cheeseburger wrap with lettuce, tomato & mayo that ... read more

Joe H. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Spur of the moment double date here recently. I was surprised by the MASSIVE menu selections; which had also left me confused and wanting to try everything lol. We ordered a few apps that were brought stacked on a nice little tower. Unfortunately this was the only pic I remembered to take. I also ordered chicken tacos and they were on point, a very good menu choice. Drinks were a bit slow, eventually we received help from multiple angles such as the manager. It was apparently our servers first night, which I can't hold again... read more

Donna K. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

I visit here about once a month. Food is always delish. Ordered the sauerbraten, meat and cabbage was great. Spaetzle was just flour and water. Need to add egg please. Disappointing. Otherwise everything was great!