Maggie McFly's | Southbury

Mike B. 

on Yelp

7 years ago

I love this place! Massive and extensive menu, that covers just about every cuisine on the planet. Have never had a bad meal here. I don't eat carbs, so I always order one of their amazing huge burgers minus the bun with a salad instead of fries, with an appetizer of just straight up bacon! Where else can you just order some thick cut bacon for a few bucks as an app?! Great atmosphere for kids as well! My 4 yr old doesn't like sauce on pizza, so I get him a personal pizza with just cheese and it's about 4 meals worth for an ... read more

Derek J. 

on Yelp

7 years ago

Came here yesterday for a late lunch / early dinner . Was greeted nicely at the door , and sat immediately . Our server came over . I was so impressed with Maggie's . I haven't been here in a couple years . We each had the choose your selection of three tacos . I cannot believe how delicious our meal was . I had avocado taco , shrimp taco , and lobster taco . It was huge . Came with two sides. One rice , one garbanzo bean and quinoa salad . Amazing meal . Fresh ingredients . Good quality . Props to the owner of this establis... read more

Kym G. 

on Yelp

7 years ago

I'm a regular at Maggie's. It's fairly inexpensive, drinks are good, service is decent. It's a good week night quick bite place. 

Tara M. 

on Yelp

7 years ago

I am always skeptical of a place that has a book for a menu... they can't make all these dishes that good!! But I have to say I was rather impressed with the few dishes we ordered. We shared a few different apps- buffalo bites, spinach dip, potato skins. The were really large plates- way too much for two people and was rather impressed with the food. Service was prompt and friendly. All in all a good experience! 

Malcolm C. 

on Yelp

7 years ago

Pro: one of the few late options in the area, lots of tvs for sports fans and a large menu, and large portions- (particularly for the pasta), cheese tortellini with sundried tomato was huge n tasty and well priced Con: menu is hit or miss, ie brussel sprouts were underseasoned, wait staff inconsistent with attentiveness, but all of this is par for the course for a high volume late night brew pub 

Tracey K. 

on Yelp

7 years ago

Hostess was friendly and seated us right away waitress was attentive and sweet. Ordered the Lobster With creamy risotto and asparagus it was delicious. Perfectly cooked! Excellent value the lobster was done to perfection and the Risotto was yummy! Keeper for sure! Great experience! Place was packed! 

Hayley B. 

on Yelp

7 years ago

I love this restaurant. It's almost like a smaller version of Cheesecake Factory. The menu is HUGE and literally everything I've had has been delicious. I've had a Cheesecake and a cupcake as desserts / cupcakes are overrated but the cheesecake was great! This is def my new go-to joint! 

Sara B. 

on Yelp

7 years ago

Have been meaning to update my post ((from 2015...oops!!)) I need to give the owner credit where it is due....Since my last post I did go back to Maggie McFly's in Middlebury - I don't think I will ever go back to Southbury!! I find the staff and food at the Middlebury restaurant just all around better. Again lots of vegetarian options and yummy apps for everyone to share. I was happy to use my $20 gift card that Ray sent me in the mail and I enjoyed my Middlebury experience and meal very much. I even went back again last su... read more

Rebecca S. 

on Yelp

7 years ago

I'm so unsure how I want to review this place. The atmosphere is great. Lots to look at and fun setting. Comfortable tables. The wait staff was great. I guess the food is my only confusion. I got a Brie and pear salad that was supposed to have a balsamic dressing and there was no dressing. I had to ask for them to bring me some and let me tell you, there's not enough dressing to drown out how awful that salad tasted. I had to tell them there was no way I can eat it. I don't normally do that. The waiter was very kind a... read more