Maggie McFly's | Southbury

Jim C. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

5/10/22 I've dined at a couple of Maggie McFly's Restaurants over the years and they are consistently........well, consistent. A perhaps overly large menu might be what keeps them mediocre instead of really good. Sometimes doing a smaller menu well is better than a large menu ho-hum. This visit my buddy had a beefsteak grinder with Au jus & fries that he said were "pretty good" I started with a cup of chicken rice soup that was "ok"....nothing special I ordered an off menu cheeseburger wrap with lettuce, tomato & mayo that ... read more

Joe H. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

Spur of the moment double date here recently. I was surprised by the MASSIVE menu selections; which had also left me confused and wanting to try everything lol. We ordered a few apps that were brought stacked on a nice little tower. Unfortunately this was the only pic I remembered to take. I also ordered chicken tacos and they were on point, a very good menu choice. Drinks were a bit slow, eventually we received help from multiple angles such as the manager. It was apparently our servers first night, which I can't hold again... read more

Donna K. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

I visit here about once a month. Food is always delish. Ordered the sauerbraten, meat and cabbage was great. Spaetzle was just flour and water. Need to add egg please. Disappointing. Otherwise everything was great! 

John M. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

Great for dinner! Good food and drinks. Been eating at Maggie's for 17 years! Friendly and very good service! 

Megan J. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

Zahnobia was so sweet. Made sure my meal was gluten free! Good food, good service! 

Dan K. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

The food here is objectively good, and I've had some amazing times here. Fantastic service. My compliments to whoever created the playlist for the restaurant, because the music is always on point. Do NOT order online. Order via phone call or just dine in. A tad expensive. 

Ben S. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

I've probably eaten at this location nearly 10 times yet never actually reviewed it (I wouldn't say it's any different than the other locations I've been to). I'm not sure if I've ever had anything that's mind blowing, but everything is solid. Their menu is HUGE so everyone can find something they want. They offer lots of options for various dietary concerns and source a number of ingredients from local farms. Location is great for meeting up with with other people as it's adjacent to the I-84 ramp. 

Mackenzie L. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

average experience. food was yummy experience was fun! definitely recommend. i recommend the potato skins for the appetizer 

Jay B. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

I've ever only done take out here. I wouldn't get all fancy and start ordering pasta dishes or fish. We get chicken wing apps chicken fingers and burgers. Can't beat it for that. Spend the extra money and get the farm to table burger and get truffle fries. You won't be disappointed.