Redeye Grill's cover image

This profile has been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Redeye Grill

4.2

About this business

Location details

890 7th Ave, New York, NY, 10019, United States

Get directions
4.27,630 reviews
Select a rating
mhdiner's profile image
mhdiner 
13 years ago

Disappointing. We have eaten here on several occasions, and there have always been some reliable choices on the menu. But something has changed. We were looking for a light supper, and ordered a spicy tuna roll from the sushi menu at $16. It arrived looking like six cupcakes, with a spicy cream cheesy kind of topping, finished off with a layer of frizzled onions! It was impossible to eat without use of knife and fork. And it was not sushi, by any definition. Another choice we tried was the crab meat salad with avocado. It wa... read more

theartfuldodger's profile image
theartfuldodger 
13 years ago

we were feted and fussed over from the moment we arrived. we've been many times before and will happily return many more times to come. amazing steaks, fantastic lobster, everything was delicious. 5 stars! 

Bethhuff59's profile image
Bethhuff59 
13 years ago

Amazing steaks. Try it with a fried egg! I loved the creamed spinach and the giant onion rings. Don't miss dessert, especially the banana cream pie. 

Alwarz's profile image
Alwarz 
13 years ago

Redeye Grill was on par with all of the Fireman's Hospitality Group's restaurants. We had a great night the food was excellent and the music fine. Service was outstanding. 

NoahD's profile image
NoahD 
13 years ago

We chose Redeye for its proximity to Carnegie hall and we were not disappointed. The wait staff was great. Throughout our meal we were offered fresh baked items from the kitchen and extremely friendly service. If I could mention one thing it would be that the food, although very good, could have had a bit more flavor. When i go to Carnegie again, I will go there. By the way, Order the "Crunchy Spicy Tuna" sushi roll... 

BJQool's profile image
BJQool 
13 years ago

Redeye Grill is always a great choice if you are looking for fresh and well made seafood. Awesome raw bar and sushi. Very cool bar scene as well. 

Anonymous's profile image
Anonymous 
13 years ago

Very good food. Excellent service. 

Rodney's profile image
Rodney 
13 years ago

Newly redecorated with a somewhat new menu. Lots of fish, but have to ask for what I consider their specialty, Dover Sole served tableside. Across from Carnegie Hall. 

like2dineout's profile image
like2dineout 
13 years ago

Really good place.Very good food. Great menu and good prices. Friendly, attentive service. 

Frequently asked questions about Redeye Grill

How is Redeye Grill rated?

Redeye Grill has a 4.2 star rating with 7,630 reviews. 

When is Redeye Grill open?

Redeye Grill is permanently closed.