Rosati's Pizza Valrico, FL

Jake K. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

My wife is from Chicago and she craves this place - like me. I would suggest you call in to order and it takes 45 minutes to make the pizzas, on a slow day - which is pretty typical for deep dish anyway. We've tried Lou Malnati's and Giordano's and this place rivals both, if you're a deep dish fan. I read some of the other reviews that ordered Hawaiian style and beef sandwiches, which I would say stick with the traditional pizza pies. We've ordered twice from there and have not been disappointed. Although, I'm quietly okay ... read more

Dan M. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

Will update my original review here as 2nd experience was better than the first thus the added star. This time around we ordered a smaller thin crust and this turned out great. Perhaps this is the trick as the 18" - per my earlier review - was just soggy and undercooked. The larger double dough we ordered had just a mass amount of cheese that gathered in the middle. This wasn't the case when we ordered a smaller double dough the first time around so I'm beginning to think that's *exactly* the trick here....order smaller ... read more

Barry C. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

I grew up in Chicagoland and for years have missed quality deep dish pizza. A friend told me about Rosati's yesterday. So, i had to try it. I ordered the sausage, onion and pepper pizza. It was good. The crust was just as it is supposed to be. The sausage was very good. My only complaint, but not a minor one, is that the sauce lacked zest. It just wasn't robust enough. If that was corrected this place would be perfect. 

Marian W. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

Decent pizza! Ordered deep dish with sausage for pickup. I was pleasantly surprised by the pie. Crust was crispy, dough wasn't heavy, (chunky)sauce was decent. Only thing I would have liked is a little bit more cheese but it was an acceptable amount on the pie. I'll definitely come back! 

Beth C. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

I'm giving 5 stars because this is some, if not THE, most delicious pizza I've ever eaten. We had a long wait, which proved to be well worth our patience. This place is fabulous. I've never had "Chicago Style" before, but I get it now!! 

Kathy W. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

We ordered pizza last Friday and it took over two hours to be ready. Apparently they had half their online orders they got ready, no show on them. It's a new place and stuff happens. When we finally got it home, I took a bite and said "OH,MY GOD!", we are from the Chicago area and I hadn't had pizza that delicious in over 20 years. Now I don't have to talk about how much I miss pizza from back home because this place is awesome! I just hope future orders won't take that long. 

J D. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

Not sure what all the hypes about. We ordered a pizza with two toppings and had it delivered. The cost was $33! They barely putting any toppings on it and the taste was mediocre at best. I'll save myself about 30% next time and stick with the mom and pop places! I appreciate the fact that they reached out, but 20% off to try it again??!! 

Paul T. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

Awesome deep dish and also thin crust. This restaurant is NOT like the other big box pizza joints. Try it once and you will be hooked! 

Lee S. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

If you grew up in and around Chicago this is a traditional Chicago style pizza place... we tried our favorites from way back when and they did a great job !!! We will be regular visitors now....