Brooklyn Diner

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

The food was delicious, and we were not crammed in like sardines! 

SandraP 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

This a a great place for lunch before a theatre matinee. The best chicken soup I ever had. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

Their mac n cheese was amazing and not typical mac n cheese 

nanrbh 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

Don't be fooled by the name. Besides the fact that there are some boths, and a bar-seating arrangement on one side, this is not really a diner. The food was OK, but overpriced. 3$ would be right, as for lunch we spent an average of $30/pp including the 18% they tack on. That was with 5 little kids and only 2 adults! Menu had a lot of nice choices. Recommend the thin pizza. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

1st time at The Brooklyn Diner. Great location. Very nicely surprised by the old school Diner decor. Food was very nice too. Ordered the Lobster Roll, which was wonderful with big chuncky pieces of lobster. Only drawback is the price of "market value" of $30, but it was delicious so can't really complain. 

EmilyF 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

great comfort food good,large portions 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

An upscale version of the usual diner with the prices to match. I brought my teens here because I was supposed to have a client meeting with them in tow, but plans changed. I would have chosen something less expensive for my kids, but they did enjoy the food and the ambiance. I imagine it's great for client meetings. 

MMill 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

Great find in the Theatre District.Delicious salads and the best chicken soup in NYC! 

foodiesforlife 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

The times Square location is definitely more cozy than the midtown location. Loved the feeling of being in an old fashioned railway car when seated at a booth. The cinnamon raisin walnut french toast was tremendous. Service was attentive, but not intrusive. Will definitely return.