Brooklyn Diner

granmasoup 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

I had made an online reservation for lunch on Sunday requesting 12:30 & was asked for an alternate time, which I requested 12:45. We took a train from Westchester on rainy day & arrived @ the Diner @ 12: 20 and were asked to wait "near the bar" till 12:45. The bar area was very crowded with mostly people waiting to be seated. There was a lot of coming & going of wait staff, customers, etc in this narrow crowded area with no seating & very little room to stand. Finally were seated @ 12:45. It too almost 1/2 hr to get our food... read more

Grammy 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

Great for kidswhen going to the theater. The booth offered a view of times square that kept their attention and the food was terrific. Their pizza is sensational, and if their prices are a bit daunting, it is still a lot cheaper than most theater area places. A wonderful staff made this a super experience. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

Good theater district location. Quick, friendly, attentive service. Huge portions, so you may want to share. It was perfect for lunch. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

Food was delicious, although the portions were miles too large. Staff is very friendly and not obtrusive and most helpful. Recommend for both lunch & dinner. Located near theater district hot spots/Times Square. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

Just an excellent, easy place for a casual meal if you need to eat in Times Square. Great service pre theater. 

shar1122 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

This was my second time at this location-The first time they ran out of their famous chicken pot pie, this time they had it. It was WONDERFUL!! Good food, great service & worth the stop. 

Martini 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

everything was excellent from start to finish 

KPxx 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

We'd been here before and coveted someone else's pizza and fries, so we ended up bringing the kids back there the next day. The pizza and fries were every bit as amazing as they looked--my only complaint about the place was the prices, but Times Square is expensive real estate. Our server was very attentive and though he made a couple of errors, was very helpful about making them right quickly. 

KPxx 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

This place is loud and pricy, as you'd expect from the area and target market, but they were very accommodating about our dessert (all we were really there for was a banana split, and it was perfect!). While we were dining, the table next to us had some amazingly delicious looking pizza and sandwiches delivered, so we knew we'd be back.