Brooklyn Diner

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

Fabulous hot pastrami on rye! We were about 20 minutes late for our reservation, and it was not a problem! Getting to our matinee on time wasn't a problem. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

Brooklyn Diner is an outstanding restaurant!! The food was amazing and the staff was phenomenal and accommodating. If you are visiting New York you MUST visit. You will not be disappointed!! 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

Best cheesecake in NYC!! 

Cleo 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

This is the prefect place for pre-theatre dining. The food is good, the wait staff is friendly and it is easy on the pocketbook. 

GerriC 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

Took my niece to dinner and a show in NYC on 5/13/17. We arrived to the Brooklyn Diner 15 minutes early because of torrential rain. It was not problem at all. We were greeted warmly, our umbrellas were bagged and we were directed to a table by the bar. We warmed up with Chicken Soup which was served in a unique way. Both had our dinners and a large cookie for dessert. The diner was cozy and we had a very nice time. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

I've been here several times and the food has always been great- try the noodle kugel. Servers are friendly, too. I highly recommend reservations, as the space is small and many groups were turned away because they did not have reservations. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

Portions were very large and impressive, not to mention very good. Great location for pre/post Broadway show. Everything was great minus the giant cookie dessert which was like a rock... 

DramaDiner 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

Great good !! We had a fantastic waitress 

Alanr 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

Every time we come to Times Square, we eat here. Love the Chicken Pot Pie. Get a River Horse triple beer. But only one! (If you want to remember the rest of the night). Small place, but it's New York. Good vegetarian options.