Brooklyn Diner

Smellykosher 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

Very expensive but the food was nice and the service was efficient and very friendly. 

debnc 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

I had a wonderful experience a few years back at the Brooklyn Diner. It was a freezing day, I was visiting NYC, it was my birthday. The food was fantastic. The bread was toasted perfectly, the waiter was charming, the food was delicious. The waiter carefully served us milk for the tea and cream for the coffee, and I was in love with Brooklyn Diner. I've been back a few times since that visit. On this occasion, portions were good, the service was efficient, but the experience did not reach the heights of my past experiences. ... read more

Ruth 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

This was our first time to this restaurant. What a wonderful surprise! Right in the middle of Times Square, the restaurant was classier than a diner, but had a large menu to choose from, modest pricing and delicious food. We will definitely be back! 

pacogirona 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

Great as usual. First visit always when in New York since my sister loves the cheesecake they have at the Brooklyn. Will come back next time ! 

KimG 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

Have been to the Brooklyn Diner countless times. Love their Tony Bennett french toast on Challah bread with strawberries and pecans!!! They are always VERY friendly and the hostess was very accommodating when we ended up arriving 15 minutes late for our reservation because our daughter uses a wheelchair and we had to deal with construction and sidewalks closed in Times Square. Have also ordered the eggs benedict and pancakes and it is always superb. The portions are extra large!!! 

VisitorFromChicago 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

Good service. Great mac & cheese. Too rich to eat too much, so share it with a friend. 

artom 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

Wish we had a diner this good on Long Island. Thanks for both of your restaurants @ Times square and Carnegie Hall. You should have more vegetarian selections. 

Nld7 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

Marketed as a traditional diner - the menu tries to recreate this Both this branch and the one at Carnegie hall are always busy. Food is nice. We always eat here every time we are in NYC. The fifteen bite hotdog is a favourite. 

RoundBrownBear 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

We visited the Diner for lunch on our wedding day with a small number of guests. The staff were exceptionally friendly and gifted us a bottle of champagne on the house. They made us feel like New York royalty! The food was fantastic - diner dishes prepared and cooked to five star standard. I would recommend this venue to anyone who wants to celebrate a special occasion in a iconic part of town or simply wants to enjoy a fantastic meal in a great setting!