Maggie McFly's | Southbury

Nicole L. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

Dirty. Service, food and cleanliness has declined over the past few years. Tonight was my last night going here. Had to swat dirty flies away the entire meal, there were dead flies on our table and asked to change tables. Service was subpar- manager never came over to apologize, server never offered refills. 

Shelly M. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

The absolute WORST service & servers! I don't know why I've given them so many chances. Obviously it comes down to management not caring either. Only go to eat here if you have all day to wait for your order to be wrong. I don't know how a server who basically works for tips can just ignore all their tables. I will never feel obligated to tip for bad service. 

Jodi G. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

bathrooms were gross. Service slow. The only good thing that we were a largish group and they had plenty of seating. Some of the food was ok, the pizza was not good at all. Menu was huge but also did not look like they wash them. 

B D. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

I went this past Saturday with a friend around 9pm. It was not too busy, and it took our waiter quite a while to even acknowledge us. We ordered a few appetizers and they could have been cooked a bit longer. Our waiter never once checked on us after he took our order. He didn't even deliver our food or drinks, somebody else did. That was the worst service I have ever experienced. I would really like to enjoy Maggie's because some food items are good, but the service and food could be a lot better. I most likely won't ... read more

Amber M. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

3 items we asked for while ordering weren't available, service was slow and 2 items forgotten, it was Mother's Day and not all tables filled, so no excuse. Went to eat left overs and they didn't include any of our dressings/sauces! What a waste! I called and spoke with the GM, Lindsay.... She should be embarrassed! Offered us a $10 gift cert for our next meal after all of this??!! What a joke! Only reason for the stars is because even though our server was slow it wasn't his responsibility for 3 food items being unavailab... read more

Diana G. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

I'd like to first start off by saying the 2 stars are for one particular server in general. I don't remember his name and my husband can't find the receipt but I think it was matt, he had a Mohawk. I've never felt more annoyed, saddened and angry before in my life. He was rude, didn't know ANYTHING on the menu. And was talking about how annoying tables are to TABLES AROUND ME! I felt uncomfortable and uneasy. Me and my husband don't make much money, so we like to splurge once in awhile. I've been here years ago and never wen... read more

Jason W. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

Very disappointed!! First we walk into a bar fight!! Then my empty glass sat on the end of the table as the waitress walked by 4-5 times! To top it off I opened my napkin and a bug came scurrying across the table, it was taken away by the staff without so much as an apology!! Cool place visually but service LACKING!! Not impressed! 

Jodie J. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

My BF and I went this past Sunday afternoon to sit at a table in the bar. It was not busy in the least, yet we had to wait quite some time to be acknowledged by the waitress, Maggie. She was a terrible waitress. I ordered an Espresso Martini , light and sweet , meaning there's a choice to have it black or with Baileys. She brought it black. We waited a while to send it back, but she never came over to check how we were doing so my BF brought it back up to the bar to have it made correctly. It did end up being extremely tast... read more

Corey M. 

on Yelp

9 years ago

Recently went here with my boyfriend. We got two drinks, an appetizer, two meals and a dessert and the price came out to over $70. I ordered the shepherds pie which was nothing like a traditional one. It tasted like an Asian dish, not at all what I expected or wanted. Their "Giant Brownie Sundae" is half the size of the one at the Maggie's in Middlebury. Extremely disappointed and not worth the price.