Redeye Grill's cover image

This profile has been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Redeye Grill

4.2

About this business

Location details

890 7th Ave, New York, NY, 10019, United States

Get directions
4.27,630 reviews
Select a rating
cappuccinoNYC's profile image
cappuccinoNYC 
12 years ago

I read that this was a good place for brunch, so decided to try it out. The restaurant itself is beautiful on the inside. It's got a great atmosphere. I was disappointed with the experience though. We arrived very hungry, and the waiter skipped over our table for bread. We had to ask someone to bring some out while we waited for our food. For the price, the food was okay. I don't think I'll go back. 

Gary's profile image
Gary 
12 years ago

As always, delicious food and wonderful service. 

ihatenicknames's profile image
ihatenicknames 
12 years ago

All the seafood is absolutely the finest. Steaks are excellent too. Great location for Carnegie Hall, City Center etc. Lobster dishes are very generous. I especially like the seafood risotto and the lobster pot pie. 

Anonymous's profile image
Anonymous 
12 years ago

What makes this restaurant that much more special is Carlo Mariani. His customer service, his warmth - is superb!!! I highly recommend to all!! Bonnie 

NYCvibe's profile image
NYCvibe 
12 years ago

I live and work in DC -- and my lady and I get to NYC several times a year for the arts and the vibe. The first or second night we're in New York we enjoy a dinner at the Red Eye Grill. The wait staff are friendly and professional and know the wines and the food. The seafood is delicate and cooked perfectly. Last weekend I had the Filet Mignon with Bernaise sauce with sides mashed potatoes and green beans. The waitress recommended a glass of Hess Cabernet. Perfection on the table! 

D2V3's profile image
D2V3 
12 years ago

My husband and I were in NYC to celebrate his birthday and Valentine's Day. The Redeye Grill was near our hotel and given the nasty weather we decided to give it a try - even though we didn't have a reservation. They couldn't have been more welcoming and accommodating. The food was fantastic and only surpassed by the service! When they learned it was my husband's birthday they went out of their way to make our dinner special. We ended up eating there 3 times during our stay and were never disappointed. We have added The Rede... read more

stephanie's profile image
stephanie 
12 years ago

Food, service, ambience very fine, enhanced by jazz duo. Prices sky high, typical of Carnegie Hall vicinity. Oysters sparkling fresh, perfectly opened, varieties distinctive. Tuna and salmon entrees generous, cooked precisely as ordered. Don't miss roasted Brussels sprouts with peanut sauce. Chocolate almond dessert unctuous. Tasty extras: warm cheddar biscuits, coconut macaroons, brownies. Then there's wine. Overpriced mostly American modest list. Out of the lowest priced white, a fairly new addition. First sommelier knew l... read more

Foodsterjoc's profile image
Foodsterjoc 
12 years ago

Red eye was good. The food was decent, the service was friendly but not necessarily efficient. The price was not worth the experience. I would suggest it to people who are visiting NYC and are visiting Times Square but that's about the only reason. 

Martin's profile image
Martin 
12 years ago

Had a great lunch on Sunday with sea food, crab cake eggs benedict and she had gorganzola flatbread and veggie risotto. all wonderful. 

Frequently asked questions about Redeye Grill

How is Redeye Grill rated?

Redeye Grill has a 4.2 star rating with 7,630 reviews. 

When is Redeye Grill open?

Redeye Grill is permanently closed.