Redeye Grill

jayjay 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

Pleasant experience. Arctic char and red snapper both delicious. Service was energetic and friendly. When a mistake was made in the bill, it was corrected with sincere apologies--though of course next time (and there will be a next time) I will remember to scrutinize the check! 

dini 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

This Carnegie seafooder still delivers after all these years. The range of options, fabulous seafood, friendly service and great ambience make this restaurant a stand-out in the neighborhood! 

ArnieS 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

The menu is always interesting and eclectic. The selection of fish and seafood always satisfies all at the table (as would any of the meat dishes I'm sure as well). Lobster and Crab meat Lasagna, variety of chilled Oysters, Branzino, were a few of the excellent choices made. Huge kudos for attention to the vegetables. The Thai/Asian flavored roasted Brussel Sprouts were a big hit! Capping off the meal with a taste of the 'Bucket of Chocolate Mousse' was certainly the way to go! The only 'miss' was the Decaf Espresso could ha... read more

tapshoes 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

delicious food. very good service. no pressure to leave. loved it 

Diner 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

Service was very good, appetizer was very good, steaks were over-cooked - we wanted medium and medium rare, they were tasty but well done. Didn't have time to send them back. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

We went on Thankgiving and chose this place because they had a 3 course traditional Thanksgiving dinner for 60 dollars per person. We started off with a salad which had cranberries and walnuts in a vinaigrette dressing which was refreshing. They were serving pretzel bread instead of dinner rolls which was really good. The main course came in a large plate and had turkey with all the fixings (a tart cranberry sauce, candied yams, Brussel sprouts with pickled baby onions and a generous dollop of mashed potatoes with gravy). I ... read more

Suzy 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

Such an amazing evening! Food and drinks were perfect and the service was wonderful, one of the best Thanksgivings ever! We also had the crab cocktail a la carte, which was probably the most delicious thing I've ever had in my life! 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

My husband and I ate here for Thanksgiving dinner, and it was delicious! It was exactly what I had wanted- comforting, traditional Thanksgiving food, done well and with a little flair. The restaurant is beautiful, and having just relocated to the city, we loved that it was right across from Carnegie Hall. 

ladd 

on OpenTable

13 years ago

We really enjoyed Redeye Grill. However, the food could have been served hotter and I had to wait 20 minutes for my coffee. Otherwise, everything was great.