Redeye Grill

MChassen 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

I've eaten at the Redeye many times over the years, but not recently. Trying it again at the holiday season was a mistake - food was generally good (however, avoid the onion soup) but overpriced, even for the location, and service was spotty at best. 

LENNY 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Food and Service was excellent. 

Knitter 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

We have been coming to this restaurant several times a year for many years. We ate here on 12/16, before a concert at Carnegie Hall. We were happy to see some excellent changes and additions to the menu. However, the service was not up to par, served oysters with out explanation of the assortment, no spoons for mignonette sauce, one main came out wrong, though they were both excellent, ( tuna and scallos)and the waiter was very frazzeled. it was obvious that the restaurant was overbooked, as we watched the maitre's offer din... read more

Keeper 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Food was VERY good. Service was outstanding. Very convenient location to Time Square hotels, but definitely frequented by more locals than tourists. Restaurant was extremely busy, yet they made us feel very special. 

boothbay 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Excellent and attentive service despite the restaurant being crowded and many people headed out to Carnegie Hall. The tuna and wiener schnitzel entrees were delicious. The butternut squash soup special was also excellent with the blue cheese adding a little zing to offset the sweetness of the soup. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Very noisy and crowded until the pre-theatre crowd left. Food was excellent and service very good. Enjoyable evening once it quieted down. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Excellent meal and great atmosphere. I would highly recommend. 

TinyDancer 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

I went to Redeye Grill to celebrate my birthday with my friends before seeing a show at City Center. I was immediately greeted by the maitre' d who offered me a complimentary glass of champagne once he learned it was my birthday. So nice! My friends were late so I made my way to the bar; but, once they arrived we were immediately seated at a cozy table by the window. I ordered a variety of oysters, the lobster mac n' cheese, and the scallops, all of which were delicious. The service was quick and attentive but impersonal. I ... read more

Lelly 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Have dined at Redeye Grill many times, and it never fails to please. The staff, in particular, are all very friendly ... and some quite witty and amusing. Food is superb.