This profile has been claimed by the business owner or representative.
Redeye Grill
- Restaurants
- New York, NY
About this business
Location details
890 7th Ave, New York, NY, 10019, United States
Get directions
Redeye was very good. However, the steak portions were smaller than our last visit. Also, we really missed the cotton candy they used to give as a surprise after the meal. That made it fun. On Sunday's, they used to give the baked goods out in little bags and we would have them on our Amtrak train ride home the next am. It's the little things that make a restaurant extraordinary rather than ordinary.
Food presentation was wonderful service was excellent Pretzel bread was a nice change Seasonings of fish were perfect and different Butternut squash soup was enjoyable When the chocolate mousse showed up in buckets this became one of my top 5 restaurants of NYC !!!!!!!! Also,loved the macaroons!!!
A great dinner and thanks for the over the top Birthday goodies!
Very good, although very pricey
The redeye grill is very convenient to Carnegie hall. They have a nice menu with fresh seafood abounding, so imagine my surprise when I ordered the famous cobb salad with crispy shrimp. I was thinking a nicely breaded fresh fried shrimp but got no more than a frozen popcorn shrimp that I have purchased many times for my young children. I was stunned!! We had a good attitude however and left humming the "gortons fisherman" song!! Other food ordered was fine but certainly won't repeat in a city where food is abundant!!
We've eaten at the Redeye several times before, though mainly for lunch. We were seated promptly and given what we think is the best table in the house, where we could see who was coming in and leaving. Our waiter was friendly and knowledgeable, but his one misstep was that he did not tell us about the specials. Indeed, we didn't know there were any until we heard another waiter recite them for a nearby table. The food was fresh and delicious. We will certainly return.
Excellent food and service...........
Great experience. We went her for my wife's birthday. We had a table by the window, great service and excellent food. I had Scallops and she had a steak. Both were very good. They brought her a coconut cake for dessert for her birthday that was really great. I would return anytime.
Really good seafood, and as strange as it may sound the mashpotatoes with lobster is worthy of being an entree. Great service.
Frequently asked questions about Redeye Grill
How is Redeye Grill rated?
Redeye Grill has a 4.2 star rating with 7,630 reviews.
When is Redeye Grill open?
Redeye Grill is permanently closed.