Redeye Grill

PDCLarry 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Redeye has the distinct advantage of location, just a minute from City Center and Carnegie Hall, a couple of minutes from Dizzies, and not far from the northern Broadway theaters. The food is competent but uninspired, and somewhat overpriced. Chicken Paillard was perfectly prepared with fresh veggies, not overcooked. Paella was good but not great; good shellfish and sausage, but missing the meat (chicken, duck or rabbit) that is part of the Valencian specialty. A small portion of "Caesar Salad" was very good, but not Caesar ... read more

sjmst 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Fun, nice looking place. They even make the kids feel welcome. Not cheap but a good value. 

larryt 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Food was very good. Table service was fair not very attentive. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

Since place was not fully loaded noise rating is N/A 

Bobkat 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

We have eaten at the Redeye before, but this was our best experiance. Our waitress was excellent. The food was better than expected. 

bandita 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

A reliable lunch spot, with lots of choices and moderate prices. The deviled eggs were a fun starter but the salmon entree was unexciting. We enjoyed the little extras the staff was passing around, including small biscuits and tiny oatmeal cookies. Service was spotty; our waiter disappeared and after a long wait we had to flag down someone to get our check. 

SandraB 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

My daughter was playing at Carnegie Hall and had a 6:30 curtain call---Restaurant was very accommodating and served us promptly. They even accommodated us by adding another chair and place settings when 2 more friends joined us. 

osiodmak 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

RedEye Grill continues to provide good food in pleasant surroundings but over the years some of the magic has begun fade. That's not to say I will not continue to use it as a great place to take friends and clients. The service continues to be good and the food enjoyable but I was a bit disappointed that my Filet Mignon was not as juicy and tender as it has been in the past. It is especially nice to plan dinner on a night when they have live jazz musicians. 

LauraL 

on OpenTable

14 years ago

We celebrated out 10th anniversary by going to many of the places we went on our first few dates, including the Redeye Grill. Now, we've been there many times between then and now and we've always been impressed. The Dancing Shrimp (all Cajun) were spiced and cooked perfectly. The Cedar Plank Salmon was beautiful. The desserts were a little on the large side, but again, great. From the moment we walked in the front door until the moment we left, we felt right at home. The service was as good as any you might find in a much m... read more