Brooklyn Diner

MaryK 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

We had a large group and wanted to to experience a great New York Sunday Brunch without having to wait for a table. Brooklyn Diner was the answer and it did not disappoint. They take reservations and their menu had something for everyone. Service was great and the atmosphere was fun. We would definitely go back. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

Very expensive. Food portions are large, though. Examples: Mac and Cheese with ham: $20.95. Chicken pot pie $24. Not really kid friendly. 

Stoney 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

The food was excellent and the service was great. The location is excellent for dinner before or after a show or a walk around Time Square. 

Mikal 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

A regular stop for us when in the area and the food and service is always consistent and enjoyable. 

FrequentRestaurantGoer 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

A perfect place for lunch. Not sure I'd trek here on a weekend, but the food was good. It was more the location I wouldn't go out of my way for. 

KellyannC 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

We were a group of 9 who did a post-matinee lunch. A great time! The food was great, and the waiter was wonderful. The only reason not five stars is that my sister's order got a little confused and the kitchen took a long time to react. But, seriously, minor flaw! You MUST have their black and white milkshake and pigs in blankets appetizer.... So fun! Also, the homemade hummus was over the top! The chicken noodle soup is fresh and flavorful, but easily a meal to itself ! Would ABSOLUTELY go back and would suggest it to anyon... read more

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

The food and ambiance of the Brooklyn Diner were good, but the service was fair at best. Although our waiter was congenial when he was at our table, it took almost the entire meal to get a water refill and his attention for a forgotten item. We noticed that the people at the next table had gotten the wrong salad. It took the same waiter almost 20 minutes to bring the correct salad. The same missteps were witnessed all around us. The food was well prepared, but not attractively presented. All in all it was a fair dining exper... read more

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

Very comfortable and good service. We have been to the original restaurant on 57th St. and found this one less hectic and rushed. It was also not too noisy to actually have a conversation. Good for a comfortable dinner pre-theater. 

NaplesMary 

on OpenTable

12 years ago

This restaurant is know for its pastrami but it was cut so thick and happened to be very fatty. The rest of our meals were fine--typical diner food which is great for after a show!