Brooklyn Diner

CarolL 

on OpenTable

12 years ago

It was a little pricier than I expected. Since the prices weren't listed on the web site menus, I had no idea. This was my second time there but I didn't remember it bring that expensive. We even shared a sandwich. 

LizC 

on OpenTable

12 years ago

We decided to go here for breakfast before a 2 o'clock show. We had 1130 reservations but when they called to confirm our reservations, they informed us that they only served break fast until 1130 and we would have to order lunch. We almost cancelled at that point but didn't and glad we didn't. We got there at 11:10 and they sat us right away even though our whole party was not there. They have one dish that was an egg cooked in challah bread with sausage and roasted peppers that was delicious. The red velvet waffle was amaz... read more

Cathi 

on OpenTable

12 years ago

I had only been to this location for brunch before. This time I stopped by for a late post-theater dinner. I opted for the lobster roll which had recommendations from other posters. It was ok; really just some pieces of lobster on a toasted roll. The fries were excellent. The wine (a tempranillo) was very good and the service was excellent. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

12 years ago

Great place for before or after the theater..... 

Sw4food 

on OpenTable

12 years ago

Adequate for pre theater. Not fineman's best. 

Statecom 

on OpenTable

12 years ago

This is my third visit to the Brooklyn Diner as always the food was great the service and accomadations by the staff from the matre de to the busboy were outstanding.We were seated promptly on arrival but my daughter had called to tell us she would be 45 minutes late.The matre de made arrangements for when my daughter arrived to put the table next to us with ours.This on a very busy Sat night.I'll be back again loved the chicken soup and chicken pot pie and the giant hot dog. 

Foodie 

on OpenTable

12 years ago

We were late in being seated and my request for a booth was not honored. The waiter was very personable. My husband' s corned beef sandwich was dry and disappointing. Dessert was excellent. Do not think we would recommend this restaurant. 

JanetPlanet 

on OpenTable

12 years ago

I grow up in NY and ate in diners quite frequently so I was looking forward to eating at The Brooklyn Diner- Times Square also. We were seated at a table for 2 which was located next to a large party and until they left the noise level was hard for my guest and I to converse. The menu had lots of choices but I was disappointed that they did not offer more breakfast items on the lunch menu. I had the salmon burger and my friend had a turkey burger and both items were good. Service was fine and the location in the theater dist... read more

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

12 years ago

The food was ok, one of the people in our party ordered a medium burger which was a little pink and bloody for our liking. Would have asked for a re-fire but the server didn't return to even fill our drinks again. We were maybe one of 10 tables occupied at the time.