Brooklyn Diner

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

We had visited last year so had high expectations! The service is quick, the staff are obliging and super friendly. The price is great given the quality and amount of food The food is to die for We love it, and recommend it! 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

The chicken pot pie is huge and great for sharing. Same for the hot dog. Every bite of the pastrami cheeseburger was better than the last. No room for dessert, but another reason to go back. 

Emptyr 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

The overall experience was good at the diner, although not exactly what we expected from a diner. I was somewhat disappointed that breakfast wasn't served all day. In our party of 6, most of us liked our meals with the bacon cheeseburger and tuna burgers being excellent. Unfortunately, the pastrami was not great quality that day, and one of our party was disappointed. The service was good with a friendly and engaged waiter. 

Jb1978 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

We were meeting a friend for lunch and decided to try the Brooklyn Diner. They had good reviews online and the location was perfect. The host was a charming gentleman, sorry I didn't get his name…loved the bow-tie btw! We were seated almost immediately and the waiter arrived promptly. Unfortunately that's the only only positive thing I can say about him. He seemed distracted and was distant and we were left waiting extra long for our meals. Once our food came everyone seemed content with their choices I loved my salmon and t... read more

Ross 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

Excellent food and fun atmosphere. Wide ranging menu of American fare. It was very crowded when we were there but they handled our table very well. 

BRBR 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

Make reservations. Breakfast stops at 11AM. Classic diner food well prepared. It was very busy and with reservations we waited 20 mins. We were going to matinee so were pushed for the time. Our waiter and the manager were very helpful getting our food out. fun experience if you want good new york city food and atmosphere. 

Bill 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

This is one of my favorite places to eat in NYC. Most recently, I went with a group of family members, some of whom were out-of-town visitors for the holidays. As always, the food was great. The reuben sandwiches were delicious, the noodle kugel was a big hit, and we couldn't resist the chocolate blackout cake for dessert! The service was outstanding -- the waitress was extremely friendly and attentive. Chris, the host, went out of his way to make us all feel welcomed. We all loved it -- will definitely be back! 

MichelL 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

Fantastic food and food presentation in what could be a touristy restaurant but is a neighborhood gem instead. Only caveat is that we waited a long time for our food (too long). This however seemed to be an isolated incident as the table beside us got served pretty quickly. They should have someone serving coffee as soon as we are seated, at least we would have had coffee while waiting. Service was really polite and pleasant and the front desk host was upbeat, engaged and did a great job accommodating us in a very busy place... read more

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

8 years ago

Brilliant food and atmosphere. Our waiter was really helpful and friendly. All staff were very nice and welcoming. We will be back!