Brooklyn Diner

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

With this restaurant sitting in such a high traffic area it actually felt like a hometown restaurant once you got inside. Big kudos to the staff on making our family of five feel so welcome on such a busy holiday weekend. 

mgreene 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

Food was very good. It was noisy and the service was a little slow. 

Ishkabibble 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

We chose the Brooklyn Diner mainly because of its proximity to the theater where we had tickets to a matinee show. We were expecting the usual overpriced burgers and salads but were pleasantly surprised by the quality of the food. The pot roast that my mother ordered with the mashed potatoes melted in your mouth and the turkey and gravy tasted like it came directly from a home kitchen. No canned stuff here. I also enjoyed the noodle kugel which I've never had before. The portions were generous which is what you would expect ... read more

gramercyfoodie1 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

consistency is utmost at this eatery...excellent service, courteous to the consumer and always reliable food 

Likes2dine 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

We went to the Brooklyn Dinner in Times Square for brunch before a Saturday matinee. Our reservation was for noon. In NYC where brunch is served almost everywhere until 2pm on the weekend, we expected to order brunch. We were handed a lunch menu and told that brunch was served until 11:00 and that you really have to be seated and order by 10:30. That is not brunch - that's breakfast. So don't say you serve brunch! We were disappointed because that is what we wanted to order. We had chicken soup (good) and their world famous ... read more

HappyGirl 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

We had an enjoyable time here with delicious food. There were 8 of us (6 adults and 2 children under age 10) and it was a lively atmosphere. We found the restaurant on Open Table when we were at NYC during an incredibly busy Xmas shopping weekend. It was a perfect place to stop and enjoy good food, right next to Times Square, before heading home. 

sperbo 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

We had a reservation for 6 pm on a Saturday evening. We were welcomed and ushered to stand at a crowded area on the right side of the restaurant. Several people were hovering over people seated and eating. At 6, we were approached and told that we would be seated soon and we were. The food was a bit on the expensive side. My wife had the trout and I had a hamburger. The food was fresh and tasty. Nothing superlative, but nothing to complain about. Given the frenetic activity of waiters coming and going, diners milling and the... read more

cdojanet 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

Every December when we visit New York, we always go to the Brooklyn Diner for brunch on our last morning before departing for home. Love their food, prime Times Square location. 

txmich 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

really liked the brooklyn diner... the baked macaroni and cheese was fabulous... the chicken noodle soup was really good... we had a slight issue with all of our order not coming out together.. we ordered 2 items off the appetizer menu and then also ordered a hamburger... the waiter thought we would want the appetizers first but those appetizer items were my lunch... the waiters should be taught to ask whether the order should come out together or at different times... it also took too long for a waiter to come to the table ... read more