Brooklyn Diner

Papa 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

Food was no more the average. The famed pastrami sandwich was good but no where famous. Wine selection practically nonexistent. 

JohnS 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

We went to The Brooklyn Diner Times Square on a Sunday prior to a Theater matinee. The location was perfect. We had a reservation for 8 and were taken reasonably quickly but put at a space that really was only good for 7. The maitre d' , however, recognized the limitations and said he would add the table for two as soon as the bill was paid. Once that happened, we were fine. I felt the restaurant handled the situation very well. I had thought at 11:30am on a Sunday that we would have a choice of Breakfast or Lunch but they w... read more

Redwildgoose 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

We went for a late breakfast, and we're so glad we did. I loved my Vernon Brown omelette. A master chef in the kitchen for sure. No not a diner but a lovely place to get world class diner food. We were impressed with the service as well. 

Matt 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

This was a wonderful day out with the girls. We had lunch a show and dinner out. The first stop was for lunch at the Brooklyn Diner. We shared three main lunches and had a great time. The food was hot as it should be and served quickly and in a friendly manner. We'd recommend it. 

Arthur 

on OpenTable

9 years ago

A beautiful, white tablecloth deli. unfrotnately, food is mediocre and prices are high. $24 pastramie sandwich. great location in Broadway area. 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

10 years ago

With this restaurant sitting in such a high traffic area it actually felt like a hometown restaurant once you got inside. Big kudos to the staff on making our family of five feel so welcome on such a busy holiday weekend. 

mgreene 

on OpenTable

10 years ago

Food was very good. It was noisy and the service was a little slow. 

Ishkabibble 

on OpenTable

10 years ago

We chose the Brooklyn Diner mainly because of its proximity to the theater where we had tickets to a matinee show. We were expecting the usual overpriced burgers and salads but were pleasantly surprised by the quality of the food. The pot roast that my mother ordered with the mashed potatoes melted in your mouth and the turkey and gravy tasted like it came directly from a home kitchen. No canned stuff here. I also enjoyed the noodle kugel which I've never had before. The portions were generous which is what you would expect ... read more

gramercyfoodie1 

on OpenTable

10 years ago

consistency is utmost at this eatery...excellent service, courteous to the consumer and always reliable food