Extra Space Storage's cover image

This profile has been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Extra Space Storage

4.8

About this business

Location details

58 W 143rd St, New York, NY, 10037, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon08:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m.
Tue08:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m.
Wed08:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m.
Thu08:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m.
Fri08:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m.
Sat08:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m.
Sun10:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.
4.84,224 reviews
Select a rating
Libby G.'s profile image
Libby G. 
rating
12 years ago

I recently rented space at this location for my business. Milton was the storage representative that helped me and he was fantastic! He was very courteous and helpful. The day we moved in, we discovered that the space we had rented was not large enough for all of the items we needed to store. Milton quickly found an additional space for us to rent. He offered us the option of renting a much larger space but I told him I would come back another day to do this. When I did return over a month later, he remembered me and had Ada... read more

Puneet T.'s profile image
Puneet T. 
rating
4 months ago

The doubled prices within a few months of signing up . I started at 120 and left at 330 within a few moths. Service is rude - if you arrive within a few routes of closing time they will not let you in . 

Mitchell G.'s profile image
Mitchell G. 
rating
5 months ago

I'm extremely disappointed by a sudden 65% increase in my rental rate. When I reached out, I was told my initial rate was 'promotional'--a fact that was never clearly disclosed when I signed up. Despite being a company that prides itself on digital convenience, they claimed to have sent notice via a physical letter rather than an email or app notification. This lack of transparency and 'bait-and-switch' pricing feels like bad faith. I highly recommend looking elsewhere for storage; there are plenty of competitors with more ... read more

Rosemeri G.'s profile image
Rosemeri G. 
rating
6 months ago

On Friday, Feb 6 at approximately 3:30 PM I visited Extra Space Storage at 581 Austin Pl, Bronx, NY to rent a unit after seeing a lower price online. When I asked the on-site manager for clarification about the online price, she responded by shouting, insulting me, and refusing to rent to me at the online rate. She also threatened to call the police and ordered me to leave. I was calm and only asking questions; the beha left me in tears . I never experienced this in my life 

Steven H.'s profile image
Steven H. 
rating
7 months ago

DO NOT RENT WITH THIS COMPANY. They are a predatory vendor. I had a storage locker for three months and then my fourth month bill arrived which was DOUBLE what I was paying. They lie and say my original rate was a promo-rate and it is month to month. I would expect a 10%, 20% increase, but double?? Run from this company!!! 

Business response:

Please contact us at (212) 694-0849 to discuss this further. 

David Y.'s profile image
David Y. 
rating
a year ago

The space and service are fine (LIC). But they are a predatory business. In one year my monthly fee has gone up by almost 70% from $185 to $315. When I started in this space it was not owned by ESS, but once they acquired it, the price increases kept coming. I am really aggravated by the price gouging. I would advise anyone looking for storage for more than a few months to go elsewhere. 

Luba E.'s profile image
Luba E. 
rating
a year ago

I made a reservation and they cancelled it without talking to me. THen I talked to 6 people, my unit was NOT available. I missed my flight to Los Angeles. Horrible company. Here is AI review: Extra Space Storage reviews are mixed, with many customers reporting issues with price increases, while others praise the facilities and staff. Some customers have experienced significant rent hikes after initial promotions, with some rents doubling or even tripling within a year. Other complaints include unexpected fees and issues with... read more

Daria S.'s profile image
Daria S. 
rating
a year ago

In the last 6 or 7 months my rent has been raised by $150. First a 35% increase on a $250 unit. Then I moved to a lower priced unit and a 40% increased was levied after one month. I was not notified in either instance. Needless to say I am in the process of moving. I had a clearance giveaway and several of the people stopped by the office because they didn't read the details of the address. At the end I was chastised, as though I was a child, because I was supposed to escort each person. This is crazy because the stor... read more

Cynthia R.'s profile image
Cynthia R. 
rating
a year ago

Beware they will increase more than 100% within a few months. Bad business practices. 

Frequently asked questions about Extra Space Storage

How is Extra Space Storage rated?

Extra Space Storage has a 4.8 star rating with 4,224 reviews. 

When is Extra Space Storage open?

Extra Space Storage is closed now. It will open at 8:00 a.m.