Casey McElroy  at Waterstone Mortgage NMLS #1826428's cover image
Claimed

This profile has been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Casey McElroy at Waterstone Mortgage NMLS #1826428

5.0
  • Mortgage Lenders
  • Winter Park, FL

About this business

FinanceMortgage Lenders

Casey is an Orlando native and a Boone High School graduate. A standout baseball player, Casey attended Auburn University on an athletic scholarship where he earned Freshman All-American and First Team All-SEC honors. Casey joins Waterstone Mortgage after playing 7 years of professional baseball with the San Diego Padres. He brings with him the intangible skills of leadership, discipline, hard work, perseverance, and punctuality into the mortgage industry. Casey takes a consultative approach to loan originating and is ded... read more

Location details

2699 Lee Road, Suite 600, Winter Park, FL, 32789, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Tue9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Wed9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Thu9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Fri9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
SatClosed
SunClosed
5.060 reviews
Select a rating
Cheryl Fine's profile image
Cheryl Fine 
recommend  Recommended
3 years ago

Casey was attentive and helpful. He really helped me get approved for the best loan for me as a first time home buyer. The steps he outlined as "homework" prepared me for final approval and closing. Highly recommend 

Business response:

Thank you for taking the time to write this recommendation, Cheryl! Providing excellent customer service, throughout the loan process, is always my top priority. I am glad we were able to provide you with a positive loan experience and were able to aid in a smooth close! I look forward to doing business with you again when the time comes. 

Daniel Cropper's profile image
Daniel Cropper 
recommend  Recommended
3 years ago

Casey was great. My wife and I were hesitant to refinance because of not knowing the process. Casey broke down the whole thing step by step and was available to answer any question we had at any point throughout the process. I would highly recommend Casey for anyone looking to refinance. 

Business response:

Thank you for this recommendation, Daniel! We know how many questions pop up throughout a refinance process – whether it's the first time you're refinancing or you're a seasoned refinancer – that's why communication is key. I hope to work with you again when the time is right for another refinance or the purchase of a new home. Thanks again. 

William Stevenson's profile image
William Stevenson 
recommend  Recommended
3 years ago

Casey provided a seamless experience as we refinanced our home. He’s was always quick to respond to a question and follow up. Highly recommend. 

Melinda Delaney-McElroy's profile image
Melinda Delaney-McElroy 
recommend  Recommended
3 years ago

I would highly recommend Casey McElroy. Our experience refinancing our home was smooth sailing with Casey. We live in California and with Casey’s expertise in presenting us with paperwork, signatures and keeping us updated on our refinance, we knew we were in good hands. He was always available to answer any questions we had. He’s very professional & easy to talk to... 💯 happy clients. Thank you, Melinda & James McElroy 

JC Anderson's profile image
JC Anderson 
recommend  Recommended
3 years ago

Casey came recommended to me from a good friend. I contacted him for information about refinancing options. He was always quick to reply whether via email, phone call, or text message. Even in one instance while he was on a trip out of state for a wedding weekend. The process was quite simple and I attribute that to his knowledge and commitment to the customer. Highly recommend! 

Jillian Quain's profile image
Jillian Quain 
recommend  Recommended
3 years ago

Casey was beyond amazing and helpful through the refinance of our home. He answered all questions we had in a fast and friendly manner and helped to connect us with new homeowners insurance. Will definitely work with him in the future, if needed, and will recommend to all my family and friends! 

Business response:

Thank you for this review, Jillian. I know how many questions pop up throughout a home refinance process – whether it's the first time you're refinancing or you're a seasoned refinancer – that's why communication is key. I hope to work with you again when the time is right for another refinance or the purchase of a new home. Thanks again! 

Ohana Huskies's profile image
Ohana Huskies 
recommend  Recommended
3 years ago

Casey is both very knowledgeable & personable which makes the home buying process so much more pleasant. We really enjoyed his assistance throughout the entire experience. 

Business response:

Thank you for your review, Ohana! The team and I were thrilled we were able to provide you with a positive homebuying experience and were able to aid in a smooth close! We look forward to working with you again when the time to refinance or buy a new home is right. Keep in touch! 

Ife Oma's profile image
Ife Oma 
recommend  Recommended
3 years ago

Casey has been a pleasure work with. I started my journey with him in February 2020 and he has been consistent with replying promptly to emails, offering suggestions for credit worthiness and giving me the best options to homeownership! I am all around a extremely pleased with his professionalism, and look forward to completing this journey with him through the home closing process. Happy House Hunting!!! 

Business response:

Thank you for sharing your experience, Ife! I am always happy to answer questions and find out what's best.  

Scott E McGlon's profile image
Scott E McGlon 
recommend  Recommended
3 years ago

Casey is awesome! He is smart, articulate, and ALWAYS follows up. Highly recommend! 

Business response:

Thanks for the review, Scott. I appreciate the compliments and recommendation! 

Frequently asked questions about Casey McElroy at Waterstone Mortgage NMLS #1826428

How is Casey McElroy at Waterstone Mortgage NMLS #1826428 rated?

Casey McElroy at Waterstone Mortgage NMLS #1826428 has a 5 star rating with 60 reviews. 

When is Casey McElroy at Waterstone Mortgage NMLS #1826428 open?

Casey McElroy at Waterstone Mortgage NMLS #1826428 is closed now. It will open at 9:00 a.m.