Barley Creek Brewing Company's cover image

This profile has been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Barley Creek Brewing Company

4.3

About this business

Location details

1774 Sullivan Trail, Tannersville, PA, 18372, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon11:00 a.m. to 9:30 p.m.
Tue11:00 a.m. to 9:30 p.m.
Wed11:00 a.m. to 9:30 p.m.
Thu11:00 a.m. to 9:30 p.m.
Fri11:00 a.m. to 10:30 p.m.
Sat11:30 a.m. to 10:30 p.m.
Sun11:30 a.m. to 9:30 p.m.
4.34,007 reviews
Select a rating
Anna L.'s profile image
Anna L. 
rating
3 days ago

Food was delicious Love me buffalo wings Service was good Nice view from outdoor patio Great stop after our wedding 

Soraya P.'s profile image
Soraya P. 
rating
a week ago

My husband and I are staying close by and seen Barley Creek Brewing Company and my husband is a big fan of all Brewers so we stopped in and Brett attended to us during the day and everything he recommended was amazing as well he also gave us some history on the place we were so happy that we came back for dinner and boy was it amazing as well the young lady who took care of us in the evening was the most beautiful sweet bartender we got there near there closing time but. Natalie was so welcoming and still took us in gave ... read more

Business response:

Thanks! Natalie and Brett are wonderful ambassadors of hospitality excellence 

Ashley H.'s profile image
Ashley H. 
rating
2 weeks ago

We had an amazing experience at Barley Creek Brewing Company and we can't thank our waiter, Joey, for being so patient with us and accommodating. We had to spend a good amount of time translating the menu for all twelve people in our family, but Joey didn't skip a beat and made sure we were satisfied with our orders and didn't miss anything. I ordered the gyro wrap and it was one of the best gyro wraps I've ever had! I also ordered a side of garlic mashed potatoes and they were to die for. Thank you Lynn to also checking i... read more

Tom K.'s profile image
Tom K. 
rating
a month ago

Excellent food and drinks! Wings were slamming. Great environment giving that mountain feel. Service was excellent! 

Nichole S.'s profile image
Nichole S. 
rating
a month ago

The bad first because it's significantly bad: Be forewarned that the chopped Ceasar salad is horrible. Like it's made of pre-shredded lettuce horrible. Nothing chopped. No romaine. No parm. Just pre-shredded lettuce and a couple of sad croutons. The dressing is not creamy; it's more vinegary and very tart. The good: while I made poor choices here, the others in my party did not. They got flatbreads which were all decent. The great: the staff busted their butts and were amazing. The prices were all very reasonable. The b... read more

Vern W.'s profile image
Vern W. 
rating
2 months ago

Did a midweek get away and found this place. Looked it up and there were pretty good reviews so we decided to try it. The staff was very nice and seated us promptly, we were sat at a table that was booth on one side and chair on the other but it was an extra tall bar stool type table. Soon as I sat down the sun was right in my eyes. Yes only a small nuisance till the bar tender shut a blind (because the bar folks were effected) but there were so many empty table. Why sit us at this table ? There were plenty of other tables ... read more

Daisy M.'s profile image
Daisy M. 
rating
2 months ago

Foods great! Fish and chips was phenomenal Wings were awesome and they give you a bunch. Kids cups, they're supposed to close fyi. Bring a kids cup if you're going for dinner and have kids 

Business response:

Thanks, Daisy, for visiting and appreciating the shout-out to the culinary team. Will discuss the kids' cup comment, as my 18-month-old grandson is not yet proficient with the lidless cups we use for our drinks. Cheers - Trip R. 

Maura S.'s profile image
Maura S. 
rating
2 months ago

This was a really cool place with a chill vibe. The service was excellent. I had the OG Burger with fries which wasn't very flavorful, unfortunately. I'd still recommend giving this place a try, though! 

Business response:

Thanks, Maura - Appreciate your photo skills. There's definitely a fine line between the perfect amount of seasoning, too much, and or not enough. With just our three kids - I can confirm - it's not a one-size-fits-all. Fresh ground salt and pepper, a side of Thousand Island, and A1 sauce should be part of the formal offer. We have a homemade dry rub made with our malt dust from the brewing process, and I have a jar of it at home that I use on the burgers I cook for myself. I expect this will get traction if I share it. ... read more

Katie C.'s profile image
Katie C. 
rating
3 months ago

Last week, my friend and I visited Barley Creek Brewing Co. after a long day of snowboarding at Camelback. We ordered the French press coffee (it was DELICIOUS) and the hot honey chicken sandwich was FIREEE. When we drove away, I noticed I left ONE of my AirPods at the restaurant. I couldn't find it outside and no one seemed to turn anything in when we went back to check. The next day, I called hoping someone had found it but no luck. I had given up all hope of finding it again but I wanted to check one more time. I called t... read more

Business response:

We're pretty good at things like this - because I misplace stuff all the time - the team is really good at finding lost/misplaced items! :) Cheers Trip R. 

Frequently asked questions about Barley Creek Brewing Company

How is Barley Creek Brewing Company rated?

Barley Creek Brewing Company has a 4.3 star rating with 4,007 reviews. 

When is Barley Creek Brewing Company open?

Barley Creek Brewing Company is open now. It will close at 9:30 p.m.