Barley Creek Brewing Company

4.3

Restaurants
Tannersville, PA

About this business

Restaurants

Location details

1774 Sullivan Trail, Tannersville, PA, 18372, United States

Get directions

Weekday	Schedule	Status
Mon	11:00 a.m. to 9:30 p.m.
Tue	11:00 a.m. to 9:30 p.m.
Wed	11:00 a.m. to 9:30 p.m.
Thu	11:00 a.m. to 9:30 p.m.
Fri	11:00 a.m. to 10:30 p.m.
Sat	11:30 a.m. to 10:30 p.m.
Sun	11:30 a.m. to 9:30 p.m.

4.33,938 reviews

Select a rating

Vern W.

13 hours ago

Did a midweek get away and found this place. Looked it up and there were pretty good reviews so we decided to try it. The staff was very nice and seated us promptly, we were sat at a table that was booth on one side and chair on the other but it was an extra tall bar stool type table. Soon as I sat down the sun was right in my eyes. Yes only a small nuisance till the bar tender shut a blind (because the bar folks were effected) but there were so many empty table. Why sit us at this table ? There were plenty of other tables ... read more

Daisy M.

2 weeks ago

Foods great! Fish and chips was phenomenal Wings were awesome and they give you a bunch. Kids cups, they're supposed to close fyi. Bring a kids cup if you're going for dinner and have kids

Business response:

Thanks, Daisy, for visiting and appreciating the shout-out to the culinary team. Will discuss the kids' cup comment, as my 18-month-old grandson is not yet proficient with the lidless cups we use for our drinks. Cheers - Trip R.

Maura S.

2 weeks ago

This was a really cool place with a chill vibe. The service was excellent. I had the OG Burger with fries which wasn't very flavorful, unfortunately. I'd still recommend giving this place a try, though!

Business response:

Thanks, Maura - Appreciate your photo skills. There's definitely a fine line between the perfect amount of seasoning, too much, and or not enough. With just our three kids - I can confirm - it's not a one-size-fits-all. Fresh ground salt and pepper, a side of Thousand Island, and A1 sauce should be part of the formal offer. We have a homemade dry rub made with our malt dust from the brewing process, and I have a jar of it at home that I use on the burgers I cook for myself. I expect this will get traction if I share it. ... read more

Katie C.

a month ago

Last week, my friend and I visited Barley Creek Brewing Co. after a long day of snowboarding at Camelback. We ordered the French press coffee (it was DELICIOUS) and the hot honey chicken sandwich was FIREEE. When we drove away, I noticed I left ONE of my AirPods at the restaurant. I couldn't find it outside and no one seemed to turn anything in when we went back to check. The next day, I called hoping someone had found it but no luck. I had given up all hope of finding it again but I wanted to check one more time. I called t... read more

Business response:

We're pretty good at things like this - because I misplace stuff all the time - the team is really good at finding lost/misplaced items! :) Cheers Trip R.

John H.

a month ago

The service and food were so great we went twice. The pocono punch was fire! The wings both buffalo and hot honey were on point, and the wings themselves were robust. I definitely recommend this place

Business response:

Thanks so much for this five-star review! The Pocono Punch really is one of the best. If I am not driving, I top it off with an 11:01 Blueberry Vodka floater! Cheers - Trip R

Sherri W.

2 months ago

We had very good service. We didn't have to wait too long for a table of six but while waiting, we enjoying the fit pit area outside. Our food and drinks came out in reasonable time. I order a flight of beer and enjoyed each sampling. I also ordered the burger with fried egg and a side of fries. I throughly enjoyed my lunch. The fries were seasoned just right and did not require any salt, pepper, or ketchup for me to enjoy. The burger was big enough were I ate half at lunch and enjoyed the other half later in the evening a... read more

Business response:

Thanks Sherri, I really enjoyed reading this review. The pictures were also very nice. Appreciate you finding us and thank you again for supporting this local brewery/distillery! Cheers - Trip R.

Tim K.

2 months ago

The food was very good but it ended there. Everyone enjoyed theirs. No one enjoyed their beer. They were flat and lacking in taste. Plenty of parking and great decor inside. The service was lacking. They left us unchecked even after walking by the table numerous times did not even look over.

Business response:

Appreciate you letting us know about your experience. Will use this as a training tool reminder at our next managers' meeting that all guests are the responsibility of the entire team - not just the assigned server. Respectfully, Trip R

Annie C.

2 months ago

Had mixed experiences at Barley Creek Brewing this winter. Having been many times previously, was excited to return. On Friday, we had a great experience with fast seating, friendly service, excellent food and drinks and beer. On Saturday, it was more crowded which is understandable. However, the hostess put us on the list , told us to wait by the bar and forgot about us. Our table was given away and it took us awhile before we got another one. While everyone else in my party had good food, the chicken on my salad ended up... read more

Business response:

Appreciate your patronage of this independent restaurant. We can indeed get busy on weekends during ski season. I'm sorry the hostess didn't find you at the bar - the phone number paging system we use to let you know your table is ready is usually spot on. All of our line culinary team members are ServSafe-certified and strictly adhere to time-and-temperature parameters for all proteins. Mistakes can happen, we'll continue to work on delivering excellent "hospitality"; One goal is to keep improving so no matter how busy... read more