Extra Space Storage's cover image

This profile has been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Extra Space Storage

4.8

About this business

Location details

3016 Express Dr S, Islandia, NY, 11749, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon06:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
Tue06:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
Wed06:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
Thu06:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
Fri06:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
Sat06:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
Sun06:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.
4.8618 reviews
Select a rating
Charles T.'s profile image
Charles T. 
rating
6 years ago

Been meaning to write this review based on our visit to the storage facility. It's clean, well managed and facilitates our space needs at a great price. Brenda, who helped us with the process is such a trip. You feel as if your family as soon as you talk to her. If you have storage needs, definitely stop by and speak with her. They honor there web flash sales in person too! 

Allison M.'s profile image
Allison M. 
rating
8 years ago

Went in today and rented a space. Manny was very friendly, courteous and helpful. He explained everything about the facility and spent a lot of time with us. We're very pleased with the service. 

Robert Lisa K.'s profile image
Robert Lisa K. 
rating
10 years ago

My room was already in the system when I arrived. After just a few short minutes of filling out paperwork, ALL computerized by the way, I was shown my room, etc. Great staff! Clean facility! Good value for your money! Definitely would rent here again... Keep up the great work! Thanks again... 

Michael L.'s profile image
Michael L. 
rating
10 years ago

I moved from a dumpy storage facility to this one after seeing how clean and well maintaned it is. Smooth floors, suspended ceilings in halls, excellent lighting. Even a indoor loading area. Carts always available. Renting it was quick and easy, with great price. Also nice and cool with the climate control. Highly reccomend this facility. 

Steven R.'s profile image
Steven R. 
rating
2 days ago

the office gets locked while the workers are driving around goofing off in the storage section. horrible service and overpriced 

Business response:

We are sorry to hear about the locked office and service concerns. Please contact us at (631) 582-8505 to resolve this. 

Frank S.'s profile image
Frank S. 
rating
2 years ago

Absolutely horrible experience with this facility. With so much competition out there you do not want to waste your time with these clowns. Very dishonest! The Owner will reply with some mumbo jumbo about how he cares and will leave his number to address any issues they have there. You be smart not to believe him. 

Business response:

We're sorry about your experience, Frank. Thank you for leaving us feedback. We will be sure to review your feedback internally. If you would like to share more details, please call us at 888-storage so that we can resolve any issues. 

Lori S.'s profile image
Lori S. 
rating
2 years ago

The place seemed like it was going to be Ok, but when I moved my stuff in one of the roll up doors was broken and same with the key pad. It took many months before they were fixed. That's not my biggest complaint. What really made me mad was they raised the rent $80 per month after being in the space for about 4 months. That's not honorable. I'm ok with raising the rent $10-$20 after a year, not $80 after four months. I recently found a much better storage place close to my home. Much more clean and the staff is very kind. ... read more

Business response:

Your feedback is very important to our team, Lori. We're sorry to hear you're unhappy with your experience. We pride ourselves on delivering clean, secure facilities and excellent customer service all at an affordable price. Your comments will be reviewed internally, so we can look into why your experience did not meet our standards. Please call us at 888-storage if you'd like to discuss your experience in more detail. 

Mrs T.'s profile image
Mrs T. 
rating
6 years ago

Was ok the first year company was called Storage post 2nd year billing was messed up had to keep calling. Then my unit became infested with mice. I was given a sticky thing and told to place it in my unit. Mice feces all over my storage tubs had to clean and disinfect. Got my things out especially after they just sold the company without any notice. Raised my rate up without notice and sent me a bill with another increase for a "billing fee"? I am very happy with my new storage unit. management does not care, I placed ... read more

Business response:

Mrs M, we really appreciate you taking the time to leave a review. We are sorry to hear about your experience and want you to know that your feedback will be reviewed internally so we can work to potentially earn your business in the future. 

Michael G.'s profile image
Michael G. 
rating
7 years ago

Be warned this place has water leaks. Had furniture in the temperature controlled unit and upon retrieval items below an AC pipe that must have leaked were covered in mold. Nothing can be done except file a claim in which I can get a total of $2,000. I paid $400 a month for over 3 years and lost over $15,000 in furniture. This is disgusting to me. You're better off selling everything or even giving it away than spending money renting a space from these crooks. 

Frequently asked questions about Extra Space Storage

How is Extra Space Storage rated?

Extra Space Storage has a 4.8 star rating with 618 reviews. 

When is Extra Space Storage open?

Extra Space Storage is closed now. It will open at 6:00 a.m.