The Vintage Cake's cover image

This profile has been claimed by the business owner or representative.

The Vintage Cake

  • Hospitality
  • Atlantic Highlands, NJ
Get directions

About this business

HospitalityWedding Planning

Location details

171 1st Ave, Atlantic Highlands, NJ, 07716, United States

Get directions
Mon9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Tue9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Wed9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Thu9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Fri9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
5.0154 reviews
Michelle Behre's profile image
Michelle Behre 
2 months ago

DELICIOUS, DECADENT DESIGNS! All I can say is WOW! Our experience with The Vintage Cake was incredible. Gina and Nancy’s booking process was seamless. From their communication, to the decadent custom design that they created for our very special wedding, Gina and Nancy designed a picture-perfect, delicious wedding cake for our Hamilton Farm Golf Club wedding. We were between a few flavors. Gina recommend a tasting to finalize our details and we were absolutely blown away. Everything was so delicious and from there we knew ex... read more

Emily Mayer Dunham's profile image
Emily Mayer Dunham 
3 months ago

Our cake was amazing! Vintage Cake made two cakes for us on our wedding weekend - the groom's cake, which we served during the rehearsal dinner, and our wedding cake. The groom's cake was a surprise from me to my husband, and they absolutely killed it with my vision - I asked for a Bryant-Denny Stadium cake since my husband is an Alabama alum and it was so fun! This cake was vanilla sponge with strawberry puree buttercream and it was insanely good. So many of our guests said it was the best cake they've ever had. Our wedding... read more

Meghan Dresen's profile image
Meghan Dresen 
11 months ago


Jennifer Jenkins's profile image
Jennifer Jenkins 
a year ago

Our cake was beautiful, classic and elegant. But most important it was delicious!! Gina was easy to work with and so nice! 

Mary Dates's profile image
Mary Dates 
a year ago

The Vintage Cake was amazing to work with! Their cakes are DELICIOUS and they have an amazing variety of buttercream fillings. We did an at-home tasting, which was easy to book and so smart! We got to take the samplings home and try them with no pressure. Our wedding cake was beautiful and simple, white with sunflowers. Our guests loved our devils food cake with cookies and cream buttercream and chocolate pearls! I would 100% recommend them!! 

Summer Lengyel's profile image
Summer Lengyel 
a year ago

Great to work with! We chose vanilla sponge cake with chocolate hazelnut buttercream and it was delicious. Gina was very friendly over email. Our cake looked exactly like the inspiration picture! 

Elsie Lee-Robbins's profile image
Elsie Lee-Robbins 
a year ago

AMAZING!!!!! Our cake was super beautiful and delicious. Nancy and Gina are amazing. I’m going to get a small cake from them again for our anniversary because it’s too good not to — I need another excuse to get more! 10/10 I would highly recommend The Vintage Cake! 

Meghan Vatter's profile image
Meghan Vatter 
a year ago

Our cake was DELICIOUS! Gina was great to work with and our cake turned out exactly how we pictured it. The flavors were fantastic and our guests loved it! 

Eliza Stacy's profile image
Eliza Stacy 
2 years ago

The Vintage Cake did a stellar job on our cake and I could not be happier with how it turned out. She took my random barrage of inspirational cake photos and designed exactly what I wanted. In addition, the cake is simply delicious, which can be very hard to find in wedding cakes. I loved the cakes so much that I had her do a grooms cake and she came up with the most whimsical and gorgeous golf/sports-themed cake that my husband was blown away by. I can’t wait to use them for all my future cake needs! 

Frequently asked questions about The Vintage Cake

How is The Vintage Cake rated?

The Vintage Cake has a 5 star rating with 154 reviews. 

When is The Vintage Cake open?

The Vintage Cake is open now. It will close at 6:00 p.m.