The Vintage Cake

Meghan Vatter 

on The Knot

3 years ago

Our cake was DELICIOUS! Gina was great to work with and our cake turned out exactly how we pictured it. The flavors were fantastic and our guests loved it! 

Eliza Stacy 

on The Knot

3 years ago

The Vintage Cake did a stellar job on our cake and I could not be happier with how it turned out. She took my random barrage of inspirational cake photos and designed exactly what I wanted. In addition, the cake is simply delicious, which can be very hard to find in wedding cakes. I loved the cakes so much that I had her do a grooms cake and she came up with the most whimsical and gorgeous golf/sports-themed cake that my husband was blown away by. I can’t wait to use them for all my future cake needs! 

Maria Ruby 

on The Knot

4 years ago

During this time of great disappointment & stress due to COVID for bridal couples The Vintage Cake shop was truly a bright spot. I had them make a cake for my son & his future wife, not only was the cake beautiful but it was delicious! My family prides themselves on being connoisseurs of cakes & this cake ranked at the top. Thanks Gina for making this a bright spot during changeling times. 

Seema N 

on The Knot

4 years ago

Ordered a cake for my son's graduation from medical school. I selected a special design with a lot of details. The cake looked amazing - a piece of art! It tasted as good as it looked. Delicious with fresh raspberries filling. Thanks Gina! 

Rachel L 

on The Knot

5 years ago

Five stars and then some! Gina and her team did an amazing job on our wedding cake and the groom's cake. I think what was most impressive was that our wedding cake was GLUTEN FREE and no one could tell. We actually got compliments on how delicious the cake was. I'm actually still dreaming of the chocolate mousse filling! She also made groom's cake modeled on my husband's R8 and nailed it. It was a surprise for him and was one of the highlights of the evening! 

Christina S 

on The Knot

5 years ago

The Vintage Cake made an absolutely AMAZING cake for my sister’s bridal shower. It was a travel themed shower and Nancy worked with me and listened to all of my questions and truly exceeded my expectations. They made a 3 tier luggage cake that was beautiful. Nothing but good things to say about my experience!! The cake was also delicious as well! We had half cannoli half cookies n cream. Delicious!! Thank you VC! 

Nicole P 

on The Knot

6 years ago

Our cake was beautiful and delicious-- it was a grey marbled fondant with gold leafing and gold fondant ribbon on the outside with devil's food cake and cookies n cream icing. It was SO GOOD! Our guests loved it. Before the big day, Nancy was such a pleasure to work with. The tasting was enjoyable, and she really helped us fine tune our vision. We also thougt their rates were fair, and they never tried to oversell us. I can't wait to have another event so we can order another cake from The Vintage Cake. 

sherri B 

on The Knot

6 years ago

I ordered my dad's birthday cake from vintage and I had no idea what to get. I sent over an image of the party theme and they produced a BEAUTIFUL CAKE that was a perfect match. It also tasted absolutely AMAZING! It was a big hit at the party and we will be ordering with vintage for all future events. They have excellent customer service, GREAT communication and their cake is delicious. It was an absolute pleasure working with them :) 

Christina C 

on The Knot

6 years ago

I reached out to The Vintage Cake to ask them to make a Grooms Cake for my now husband at our wedding. I wanted something that would surprise him and be just a huge hit. Well, I asked and they delivered! They made the most amazing NY Rangers grooms cake for our wedding. Not only did the MSG stadium look phenomenal, but the cake tasted absolutely delicious as well. Everyone was crowding around this cake taking pictures and people are still talking about it 2 months later. I can't thank The Vintage Cake enough for making such ... read more