54th Street Restaurant & Drafthouse

Bessie H. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

I was very disappointed with my visit here. I've always passed by this place and said I wanted to go so today was my first time visiting Street54 because I wanted something different. I ordered the Blackened Salmon with the adult Mac and cheese and was very unhappy about my first time being there. My salmon was over cooked and the Mac and cheese had a tart flavor. I told the waitress that my salmon was over cooked she said sorry and walked away I then asked for the manager and explained to him that my salmon was over cooked ... read more

Dave W. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Not a good experience today for lunch. We were seated at a booth which seats and table was very wet. Once tabled was dried off waitstaff took our order, we waited over thirty minutes no food. Waitstaff had stopped by several times to inform us the food would be right out. We walked out. 

Andrea H. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

My company went out attempting to enjoy some food and drinks after a long day of work. Myself and a group of coworkers were having a good time in the bar area, until one of the waitresses told us the manager said they could no longer serve us. We were all appalled because after racking a tab of SEVERAL hundred dollars, apparently our money was no longer good here. The manager's excuse was that "for everyone's safety, no more drinks". In the matter of 3 hours, each person had maybe 2-3 drinks MAX. It was so unbelievable and w... read more

Chassity D. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Manager is a jerk! We had a reservation for 5:30 for a company happy hour in the bar area. They cut off at 9pm after each person had max 2 beers and/or a shot. Thought this was a bar. Total was well over $700 (food and drink). Guy cared nothing about this disservice affecting the waiters' who served us tips. The company usually tip very well but, nope not tonight. FYI we took a photo of the receipt so don't try anything illegal. 

Double D. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Good happy hour menu. Service was a little slow, but it was pretty busy. For the happy hour menu & drink we will be back. There crab cakes were good and a good value. Long Island Tea at HH is a good deal too! 

Jaqui C. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

I absolutely love the environment here. Delicious food, drinks and great service. Lindsay is the best and always takes care of us!! 

Brittney H. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

First timers and we loved it. This Alfredo tasted so creamy and flavorful, it wasn't too salty. I would say this is one of the best alfredos I've had. The veggies were seasoned perfectly, it had like a lemon little zest to it. The garlic bread was good too. The best part of the chicken tender basket was the coleslaw, it had such a fresh and unique taste. Loved it! Chicken and fries were good 

M J. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Bartender refused to serve us drinks because we had New Jersey licenses. Took our licenses to the manager who "did not feel comfortable serving us" and spoke to us condescendingly after refusing the drinks. 

Mark H. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Well I had never been here and my wife convinced me to leave the place we were and swing in. We walked in and went to sit at the bar. There were 4 open seats and all with dirty dishes in front of them. The people said no one was there and there was a clear nasty liquid all over the bar top. There were four bar tenders, two men and two women. They never greeted us. They never removed the dirty food dishes or cleaned the bar top. They all looked at my wife and I but continues thiernconversations for over 5 minutes. We finally ... read more