Brooklyn Diner

MariaM 

on OpenTable

6 years ago

The menu had changed a little since we were last there which was very disappointing to our kids who were looking forward to certain items. We’d even looked at the menu online the night before and that hadn’t been updated. Overall the food was decent and the portions were reasonable for the price. 

HotTamale 

on OpenTable

6 years ago

Host was super nice. Waiter was nice but very slow and not the most attentive. Food was great and had a fun seat by the window. Will give it another go another time. 

Travellingmax 

on OpenTable

6 years ago

The restaurant was packed, the noise level very high, the chicken in the pot yummy. Everyone was happy with their meal. Next time we shall return to the Brooklyn Diner updpwn. More our style. 

CharlesP 

on OpenTable

6 years ago

We love the Brooklyn Diner on 57th Street, and now we love the one on 43rd. The chicken pot pies at both places are hard to match. The giant hot dogs are delicious. The staff is very friendly and accommodating. 

StephenA 

on OpenTable

6 years ago

Always the first please to eat when we arrive in New York 

EdJo 

on OpenTable

6 years ago

I had the chicken pot pie which was delicious and huge. The puff pastry on top was perfect. The turkey reuben was good as was the chicken Cubano. It is a bit more expensive then other diners in close proximity but the quality of food and service was higher. Our waiter was great. 

wabobx 

on OpenTable

6 years ago

Aunt-Niece girls weekend. Excellent food. Convenient location and a real diner. Loved it. 

BethK 

on OpenTable

6 years ago

We have been visiting The Brooklyn Diner for lunch for over 10 years now. It is a must for the holiday season, and highly anticipated every year. The food is always beyond delicious and the service is impeccable. We truly cannot wait to come back, and enjoy this experience once again. 

KathiM 

on OpenTable

6 years ago

Food was very good a little expensive. Our waitress was fantastic.