Maggie McFly's | Middlebury

4.1

Restaurants
Middlebury, CT

About this business

Restaurants American Bars Seafood

Location details

6 Woodside Avenue, Middlebury, CT, 06762, United States

Get directions

Weekday	Schedule	Status
Mon	11:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
Tue	11:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
Wed	11:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
Thu	11:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.
Fri	11:00 a.m. to Midnight
Sat	11:00 a.m. to Midnight
Sun	10:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m.

4.13,247 reviews

Select a rating

Mai L.

3 days ago

I've been to a different location before but not here. We were seated pretty quickly on a Saturday night. We got to sit upstairs which was cool to be able to feel a little separated. I ordered the pot roast and it was pretty good. Loads of food and I like that it was topped with the crispy onions. Our server was also very friendly and service was pretty quick.

Stephanie G.

a week ago

Food and service were both absolutely amazing!!! Ambiance is always amazing and makes you feel comfortable and at home.

Business response:

Hi Stephanie, We’re so glad to hear you had such a wonderful experience! It’s great that the food, service, and ambiance all made you feel comfortable and at home. Thank you for sharing, and we look forward to welcoming you back again soon! Best, Team Maggie McFly's

Brian B.

3 weeks ago

Family of five adults for lunch, enjoyed the great food and the excellent service (thanks, Jayden). Pot roast, burger, fish n chips, and BLT were all very tasty. Plenty of seating, not too crowded. Looking forward to next time!

Business response:

Hi Brian, We’re so glad your family enjoyed lunch with us! It’s wonderful to hear that the food was a hit across the board and that Jayden provided excellent service. We’re happy the atmosphere felt comfortable and not too crowded as well. Thank you for sharing, and we look forward to seeing you all again next time! Best, Team Maggie McFly's

Marc A.

4 weeks ago

Our go to restaurant, never had a meal that wasn't above great. Great food, great service, great people. You gotta go!

Business response:

Hi Marc, Thank you so much for your kind words! We’re thrilled to hear that every meal has been a great experience for you. We can’t wait to welcome you back for your next visit! Best, Team Maggie McFly's

Dakota S.

a month ago

Food had gone down hill recently, used to frequent this location - but not anymore. Sad they took the pilgrim sandwich off the menu....

Business response:

Hello Dakota, Thank you for your feedback. We’re sorry to hear that your recent experiences haven’t met your expectations and that you miss the Pilgrim sandwich—it’s always tough to see a favorite menu item go. We truly appreciate your past support and will share your comments with our team as we continually work to improve our menu and quality. We hope you’ll consider giving us another chance in the future to show you the experience you’ve come to enjoy. Sincerely, Team Maggie McFly's

Mirian G.

a month ago

I came here with my boss for a working lunch and had a great experience. I made reservations the day before, and we were seated in a cozy upstairs booth, which was perfect for a productive yet relaxed lunch. My boss ordered the New England clam chowder and beef skewers, and I had the lunch Greek salad along with the fried calamari. Everything was delicious, fresh, and well-prepared. The service was quick and attentive, which we really appreciated during a workday. The menu offers a wide variety of options, which can feel a... read more

Business response:

Hi Mirian, We’re so glad to hear you had such a great experience, especially for a working lunch. It’s wonderful to know the upstairs booth was a comfortable fit and that the food and service helped keep things both productive and relaxed. We’re happy everything from the clam chowder and skewers to the Greek salad and calamari hit the mark, and that the quick, attentive service worked well with your schedule. We appreciate you sharing such thoughtful feedback and look forward to welcoming you back again soon, especially wit... read more

Marianna V.

2 months ago

We had a great family dinner there during the holidays. We topped it off with their s'mores campfire style dessert- so fun and festive . The only drawback was the draft near our table every time the door opened, and the waitstaff was stretched too thin so our service was slow- patience required here but the meal was delish!

Business response:

Hi Marianna, Thank you for sharing! We’re so glad you and your family enjoyed a holiday dinner with us, and that the s’mores campfire dessert added a fun, festive touch to the evening. We appreciate you mentioning the draft near the door and the slower service during a busy time. Your patience means a lot, and we’re happy to hear the meal itself made it worthwhile. We hope to welcome you back again soon, maybe under a little cozier setup next time! Best, Team Maggie McFly's

Jennifer M.

2 months ago

I ordered the Bourbon Ribeye (medium well) with garlic mashed potatoes, and it was amazing. The steak was flavorful, tender, and cooked perfectly, with a rich bourbon taste that really stood out. The garlic mashed potatoes were creamy, well seasoned, and the perfect side. Everything arrived hot and fresh. Definitely ordering this again.

Business response:

Hi Jennifer, Thank you for sharing! We’re thrilled to hear you loved the short rib grilled cheese and fries. It’s wonderful to know it hit the mark as a comforting, flavorful meal. We appreciate your recommendation and can’t wait to welcome you back for another delicious visit! Best, Team Maggie McFly's

Jennifer M.

3 months ago

I ordered the short rib grilled cheese sandwich at Maggie McFly's, and WOW it did not disappoint! The sandwich was packed with tender, flavorful short rib, perfectly melted cheese, and grilled to golden perfection. The fries on the side were crispy and delicious, the perfect match to the sandwich. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and honestly one of the best comfort meals I've had in a while. Highly recommend!

Business response: