Maggie McFly's | Middlebury

Dee N. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

Only giving this place Five Stars for the food and our Waiter, Mitch. He was excellent and made the experience so much better for my family and I. Provided fast service and apologized for the kitchen being behind on such a busy night. Other than that, it took quite some time to be seated and the management was no where to be seen. I work in restaurants myself and it is very important that the manager stops by the tables at least once during the meal. I'm not sure if the restaurant was too busy and they needed to help cook or... read more

Heather P. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

I been coming here for over 17 years. The service is always good except for a few occasions. Otherwise the food is excellent. It really doesn't matter what you order it's all great! My only complaint is recently the portion size is smaller especially on the bowls. 

Will H. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

Maggie McFly's is a great restaurant with an interesting menu. I love how they source a lot of their food from local businesses and the menu provides some context. Drinks are great and wait stuff is always courteous. The are not really kids friendly and the drinks are over priced. Besides that, it a great franchise 

Mich R. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

Maggie McFly's menu is HUGE! If you are indecisive like me, make sure you read the menu at home before you come here or your friends will hate you. There is so much food to choose from here, it's hard to make a choice. I ended up choosing the Ahi Tina Poke Stack for $11.99, which was well worth the money. I ended up getting this as my entree and it was enough food to fill me up. The sushi grade tuna was nicely stacked atop rice, with cilantro, ginger, sesame oil, avocado and other sauces. The presentation was a nice addition... read more

Jennifer J. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

Positives and negatives. Food was yummy. Portions were weird and inconsistent. Service was slow and not happy at all. I'll be back to try new items and hope for a better time! 

Ali R. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

If I was basing my rating on food alone, I would give it a 5. The food was great. I've never had a Cuban before but after having the one here, I want to know what an authentic Cuban tastes like because it was very delicious. The Eggplant fries were good but I've had better at other places. I would order them again if I went back though. But since I'm basing it off of food and service, I have to say, the food was great. The bartender was ok. He wasn't awful or amazing, he was just there. Politely taking my order and cashing ... read more

Angela O. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

My husband and I have been traveling all day, we were served an amazing dinner for a reasonable price. The staff was friendly and very helpful. It seems most of the guests were locals. Everything looked delicious! 

Kristen L. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

We love you Maggie's! Really we do! Huge menu, kind staff, and we love that you use fresh local ingredients in your menu as well! Just wanted to leave a thanks for always being consistent and pretty damn delicious! 

A G. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

I love Maggie's I do- the noise level is horrible. You can never hear yourself. I feel like the menu is overwhelming but the food is always good. Always a good portion that can be taken home for left overs