Maggie McFly's | Middlebury

Katie L. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Maggie McFly's is one of our favorite restaurants. Wide menu, consistently good food, food allergy friendly (gluten allergy). We're never disappointed with our actual meals, but the delivery and pick up services are atrocious. Any time we order takeout, it's never ready on time. Tonight's order said it would be ready for pickup in 25-30 minutes. This was at 7:42pm. It took over an hour for TWO SALADS to be ready. At the end of a long work day, when we're just trying to grab a easy meal for dinner, it's extremely frustrating... read more

Jessica W. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Quantity & quality for sure! The food is so good and you get an abundance of it! So many options to choose from on the menu so be sure to check it out online before you visit. Or you may spend most of your time reviewing the menu. Options for all different foodies both young and old. 

Kara F. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

We go here for last minute dinners if we're too lazy to cook. Food portions are large and they have a huge selection along with drinks. However, consistency is not there. We have ordered steak egg rolls and they either come out cold or undercooked so the roll is mushy. Staff need a lot more training, bartenders are inattentive. We did not get silverware or plates the last 3 times we ordered food to share. So we had to sit and wait until someone came by. We only continue to go there for last minute dinners but not because of ... read more

Charlene P. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Love Maggie McFlys!!!!!!! How ever will never never use grub hub again to order from there ... I would of never ordered from Maggie's again if I didn't find door dash also delivers fro there ! 

Rebecca B. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

I went for linch one day, sat at the bar and ordered the shepards pie, the serving was enough for two meals and was obviously home made and delicious. The bar is large enough to make it fun if you want to or have some quiet space if you are in the mood. The bartender was very friendly and attentive. The menu is basic American and restaurant is large with outdoor dining, always a great option. The manager was visible and connecting respectfully with the customers. Establishment was clean and cozy, definitely one of my spots, ... read more

Lyana R. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

So this was the second time a gave Maggie McFly's a try and I'm so glad I did. The first time I went last year I was so overwhelmed with their 40 page menu... now since the pandemic the menu is concise and the quality of the food is wayyy better!! So the interior is fun! It's got a huge plane inside and the decor is like rustic meets industrial. The waiters are super nice! The menu has different options for gluten free, vegan and carnivores of course lol!! The size of the plates are huge! I truly loved that my tacos were of... read more

Lauren R. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

I've been here a few times before and have always thought that this is a great restaurant with a lot of options, but the last time there was a huge decline in quality. Before now I probably would have given a 4. I've always really liked the burgers here, and had the wagyu burger last time. It was a little soft (probably because of the wagyu meat) but had a good flavor. The one major issue was the fries, which I luckily didn't really feel like I needed anyway, because otherwise they would have needed to get sent back. They we... read more

Erin S. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

I am immediately struck with nostalgia every time I walk through the doors of Maggie's when I smell the wood burning. This institution has been present throughout my life growing up in the area. I even worked here briefly until I dumped a beer on a customer - not good. But I have spent many an evening in the bar in my twenties and thirties- and I have enjoyed bringing my own kids after a day at the lake. I almost always order the buffalo chicken salad and the spinach and artichoke dip. The menu is almost overwhelmingly large... read more

Amelia Z. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

Had a bad experience with a take-out order a while back, I must say I had to change my rating to five stars. Since Covid I've been ordering often thru doordash, I always have modifications, sauce requests (Maggie's makes them in-house soo good) and they've improved tremendously, everything is always absolutely perfect!