Redeye Grill

patd 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

The Lobster roll consisted of 4 small pieces (not even 1 leg's worth) of meat on a burnt roll; plus the meat was tough. We specifically asked if the lobster was in butter or a mayo base and were told mayo - it was in butter instead. Another guest ordered a steak, which was cooked correctly, but I have never seen a steak served with absolutely no garnish - just a steak on a plate. For $35 I would expect a small salad or a couple vegetables on the plate. The chopped salad was as expected, but the nicoise was very small in comp... read more

FrankinWM 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

Food was average, friendly service but not attentive. Waiter took away my silverwear then served my dinner, I had to request silverwear once I was able to flag him down. Water glass not refilled. Poorly situated table/chair - every guest and every waiter that passed by my chair banged into it. 

Gordon 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

My wife and I have been to this restaurant several times over the past few years and always had a good experience, and that is what we expected when we invited some friends who had never been there before. Unfortunately that was not the case at a dinner on the Saturday after Christmas (about 6:30). The dining area was so crowded that wait staff could hardly get by. We were shown the worst table (slightly late for our reservation) when others were available. Service was very rushed (the main course was delivered while we were... read more

LMKManhattan 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

Had pre-theater dinner here two days ago. The fare was mediocre steakhouse food. There are so many excellent steakhouses in the city, why would you bother to come here unless to be close to Carnegie Hall? Appetizers and sides were mostly unimaginative and tasteless. Bread selection was dry and tasteless. Cappuccino was weak and cold when it arrived at the table. I don't mind spending good money for excellent food. But this establishment is extremely expensive for marginal food with service to match. It felt like the staff to... read more

jgold 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

over-priced, over-priced, over-priced, over-priced, over-priced, over-priced 

LongIslandLady 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

We decided to lunch here and ordered the $30 price fixed meal. We have eaten all over the city and had many price fixed lunches. The portions were small- spicy salmon sushi roll on the regular menu was 6 pieces and my portion was 3. My husband had the chicken and the cucumber salad was minuscule . When I write these reviews , I give an opinion on the value of the meal . This was not a good value and we will not return here when there are many restaurants in the ares that have a better value. Sometimes restaurants just charge... read more

DanD 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

The hostess did not explain that she had already seated one of our party and we were searching the restaurant for the person. We were not asked about a drink for at least 10 minutes after seating. The bread was close to stale, The food was adequate, but really overpriced. The signature salad dressing tasted more like water. Everything was ala carte. Great atmosphere but not enough to overcome the other shortcomings. 

DiningMyWayThruLife 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

I have eaten many times at Redeye Grill and therefore, treated my family visitors there. Although our waiter was not very busy, my water glass sat empty for 15+ minutes several times and our drink orders always took 15+ minutes to arrive after we were finally able to get the waiter to our table. This is it anything what I have experienced in the past. Our bill for 3 people was $325 before tip and I expected better service. 

pseudonym 

on OpenTable

11 years ago

Menu offering notably missing the "dancing shrimp." We liked the new more open seating & bar. Great service. All food was unfortunately lackluster or bland. Disappointed with appetizer sashimi yellowfin, crab & lobster lasagne, diver scallops. Would give 5 stars but just not worthy.