Redeye Grill

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

Overpriced for averge food. Will not go back. 

WilliamP 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

I've been to the Redeye a number of times in the past, and had good experiences. And the food, particularly the seafood, is very good. But this time the service was lackluster, like we were an intrusion. Our waiter seemed to enjoy talking to the other waiters, and did not seem interested in us. The location for those with tickets to Carnegie Hall or City Center can't be beat. But given the prices charged, they need to up the level of service provided. 

staceyc 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

I've been wanting to eat at this restaurant every time we go to Manhattan because it's very close to our apartment. On this trip, it was me and my teenage daughter and the service bordered on negligent. I ordered a glass of wine at the bar because we were told that, even though we had a reservation, it would be a 20 minute wait unless we wanted a "very cramped table." Shortly after I ordered a glass of the "house wine" for $15, our table was ready. When I looked at the wine list at the table, there was no wine for $15 per gl... read more

MarkH 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

For tourists who don't know truly good NYC food. Overpriced and not what it used to be. 

KimC 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

The food is nothing to speak about - standard steaks. For the price, I'd rather go elsewhere. 

NicoleS 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

I really use to love Redeye Grill. But I feel the quality of the food has changed. Also, charging $5.00 for a soda is insane. Not sure when we will be going back. The place was very empty on a Friday...says a lot. 

Foodieforsure 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

all was good--except we both ordered the sole and my friend had lots of bones in hers.... 

Anonymous 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

VERY DISAPPOINTED TO BRING IN A PARTY OF 7 FOR VALENTINES DAY TO ORDER SCALLOPS AND YOUR RESTAURANT TO BE OUT OF THEM AT 7:30???? 

JSBa 

on OpenTable

15 years ago

Overall food and ambiance was very good. However, on this particular evening, the server was not attentive and slow to take our order. It was not a busy night therefore I was surprised by the slow service.