Brooklyn Diner

Michelle 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Our experience was good overall. We had good service. The food was very good - my nephew especially loved the steak frites. The only exception on the food was the grilled chicken on my Cobb Salad which was so overcooked that much of it was inedible. That was a shame because the rest of the salad was good - very fresh and not overdressed. We tried the strawberry blonde cheesecake and it was excellent. 

HarryBayreuth 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

A Perfect Place Breakfast. We come from Germany and relaxe and enjoy a Start in a Perfect das. Thanks NYC 

MayM 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Through me for a loop. First of all, it's not in Brooklyn. Second, it's not a typical diner (won't find breakfast for dinner). The pollo cubano I ordered is now my fave dish. Can't wait to try it again. Service was attentive but not pushy. Environment was a bit noisy at dinner time (on W 43rd) but we could still have a conversation without shouting. Overall good experience. Clean and friendly. 

Danaluv 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Pre theater brunch was good. Service not as good. Had to ask twice for side of noodle kugel that I ordered but was not delivered with meal. Juice which came with NY breakfast was also not delivered until asked for, and then it was the wrong juice. My egg white omelette with mushrooms spinach and tomato was good and we liked the side of polenta with dipping sauce. Two eggs over easy were done well and sausage was tasty. We loved having a choice of challah toast. 

Todd 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Portions are huge. SHARE! Food was good - we had the massive hot dog, and it was actually quite good. The matzo ball soup was better than expected, considering the place is not 2nd Ave Deli, and the chicken pot pie was OK (and yes, very large). Didn't have dessert, unfortunately, but they did look very good as they passed by. A decent choice for the theater district, especially for tourists. Not surprisingly, it is overpriced (though not at all crazy for the potion sizes). 

WhiteRose90 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Nice diner for a quick pre-theatre meal. Busy and somewhat noisy but the food was good. Their Chicken Pot Pie was very good and can be shared by 2 people if you are light eater. In spite of how busy it was, service was good. 

GraceW 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

The food and service were good. Serving size was a bit large. The price was high for the food. We could have eaten at a better place for what we got. 

Momsdayout 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

We booked our resv for the Times Square location by mistake but went to the Central Park location. Even though I mixed up our reservation, they were very accommodating, informed the TS location of the mix up & sat us within minutes. Excellent service. Food came out very fast & was delicious. Will definitely be eating there again. 

JamieM 

on OpenTable

5 years ago

Ambiance is fun and location to Times Square is fantastic, but it definitely feels like they are taking advantage of the tourist crowd. It took over 15 minutes for anyone to acknowledge our presence and take our drink order. The waffles tasted packaged, not fresh. The service definitely got better, but not without making it clear that we weren't happy. We wouldn't recommend it.