Maggie McFly's | Middlebury

Maggie P. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

I was very disappointed with my lunch today!... no tartar sauce with my fish and chips?.... that's a sin to a good restaurant. The coleslaw was packed with the hot fish and ff it melted the mayo and make the cabbage saggy and warm with no crunchiness touch. The two stars are for the fish that was ok, nothing special. 

Dan M. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

This place is terrible, I've been here 3 times and the service is always terrible. However my daughter in-law loves it and we decided to bring her for her birthday. We made reservations in advance but when we got here the hostess said she gave our reservations to someone else and there nothing they could do. They then put us on the waiting list where we waited for 30 minutes. We complained to the manager who shrugged and said "sorry". To top it off the hostess who gave our reservations away was very rude to us and never apo... read more

Conni H. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

Way way way too pricey. A corned beef and cabbage dinner @ 18.95.thats a cheap meal to make, it's not like its seafood or a good steak. 

Garin L. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

When we ordered a kids soda was $1.75 but a kids strawberry lemon aid is $3.25 (twice the price) and prices are not listed for these drinks on the kids menu. Waitress did not tell us that this was even going to be an up charge. Second issue that day was the soup and salad special that my wife ordered looking at the lunch menu; but, received salad, from the kitchen, from the dinner menu instead, which was not on special for that price savings. Ask to see the manger about what she could do but only received a blank "don't care... read more

Anderson M. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

Unfortunately the meal my husband and I got tonight was super disappointing. The amount of grease on the burger/buns made it next to impossible to eat, and it was lacking flavor of any kind. The French fries were stale, as well as the cookie cup cake. On a positive note you can tell it was a good cut of bacon. 

Maya O. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

Maggie McFly's was probably one of the worst dinners I have ever had. There were flies everywhere, you had to fight them for your meal. It was disgusting. It would have been a little better if the food was good, but it wasn't. I got the steak it was completely raw. When I asked them to fix it they overcooked it until it was dry. Even the sides were just absolutely awful. The staff weren't to nice about the issues. They argued with me about how the food was cooked. My family and I all had issues with are food, they all compl... read more

Anna L. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

Absolutely do not recommend take out. Have gotten take-out from here many times and at least one meal is missing every single time. The salad had several pieces of hair in it. Eating in the restaurant is a better experience, but not by much. 

Erik T. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

An interesting looking place from the outside that I visited on the recommendation of a local. The menu is big, like Cheesecake Factory big. The idea is to be farm to table in theory where they use local ingredients from small family businesses. Had a real nice adult beverage menu and selection was very good across the board with a few pages dedicated to alcohol alone. So after reading the menu like a child bedtime story I ordered deviled eggs and paella. The eggs were ok..they still had the bite of the fridge which I guess... read more

Jerri S. 

on Yelp

6 years ago

Awful. Good for a beer and thats all. Ordered a pizza the dough, which is store bought, was doughy and the cheese was a thick chunk of room temp cheese, tomato was fresh sliced but not warmed, a sprinkle of sauce on it. Size of pizza was Small for 13.99. Go for a pizza but not a pizza.