Maggie McFly's | Middlebury

Art V. 

on Yelp

3 years ago

I came with a friend last night for a nice relaxing evening and good food. I've come to this restaurant many times in the past and watched it go downhill. Last night was the worst. It took over 10 minutes for the waitress to greet us. The restaurant was not really busy I must add. It took another 10 minutes to get water after asking if we wanted drinks. We then ordered French Onion Soup and an entree. It took roughly 15 minutes for the soup to arrive and the cheese on top was not even melted. The soup was served luke ... read more

Justin Kelly A. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

This used to be my go-to place that I used to love! I would go at least twice a week between dinner, lunch, or drinks with friends. The food is still decent however the wait times and lack of attention from staff is very disappointing. I gave excuses of her covid that ...well, was covid. I gave excuses in the spring 2021 that everyone was short-staffed due to stimulus packages and people staying home. But now?... It's been 40 minutes and we're still waiting to pick up our meals for take out. It'll be quite a few years bef... read more

Steven B. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Was here last night. We sat outside on the patio, it was very nice. However, the Food was just ok, but I ordered a burger w/ brie and fig jam. I specifically told the waitress I wanted more fig jam. The burger arrived with NO jam at all. Also, had to call out the cheese police - hardly any brie cheese at all. It was disappointing to say the least. We paid the bill and left a nice tip. However, my friend wanted a 2nd cup of coffee. Our waitress couldn't be bothered because she got paid. I had to ask another waiter for ... read more

Rebecca R. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Horrible service, food was terrible and took over 30 mins because we weren't friends with the servers or other workers. The ramen dish came out with noodles that were almost mush and the broth and soup itself wasn't hot. The chicken Caesar salad was mush and the French onion soup was nothing like it used to be, don't waste your time give up on Maggie's, we've tried multiple times because we used to love it here but it's gone under! 

Trouble M. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

So my boyfriend and I went for a late dinner. The place was not very busy and at least to me did not look understaffed!? I do not remember ever eating out at Maggie McFlys before so we thought it would be a nice change. It was exceptionally cold where we were seated but did not ask for a change. The drinks were specialty cocktails and they were okay but not the best. The onion rings were the highlight of the night and we wished there were more! The entrees came to the table and did not seem to be same amounts for a dinne... read more

Brittany L. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

We came in got seated upstairs it seemed pretty busy this Sunday evening we noticed right away our waitress was favoriting another table near us and unfortunately that caused our service to be extremely delayed which we were really unhappy about we ordered a nacho platter it came with beans cheese chips salsa guacamole and sour cream was put on the side as we asked. Ordered a southern chicken sandwich, and ordered a bbq burger both with regular fries. Service was ok we waited about 15,20 minutes to even have a waitress or w... read more

Sarah L. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

I don't know what exactly is going on at that place, but this is the second time my order has been delivered wrong or inedible. I ordered the bacon cheeseburger medium rare. Definitely not. I also decided to treat myself to some cheesecake. I figured if it was $8 then it must be good! HOLY CRAP WAS I WRONG. I received a stale, clearly store bought, smashed tiny slice of what smells like feet. Are you guys serious?? Never again. You've lost a patron for life. 

Camron C. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

Everything here is slightly below average except the prices. We live close by so we really wanted to like this place and gave it multiple tries. We chalked up our past not so good experiences to off nights or just the staff having a bad day. Food quality is low, service is just eh, and prices are too high for what you get. Just seems that as a whole, the staff just doesn't really care. Better off going to some of the spots in Naugatuck like 66 Church, The Hub, or even The Station. 

Nicole R. 

on Yelp

4 years ago

This review is not for the service at all. Both my boyfriend and I went inside the middlebury location to order "takeout" . We went inside and ordered and waited for our food, which mind you came out in a very timely fashion. The restaurant was pretty dead for a Saturday so I actually figured the food would be done quickly. What I didn't figure was when I got home with my order that I would see 3 chicken tenders in my order. 3!!! I paid 12.99 for 3 chicken tenders and a half pound of French fries. I am so disgusted at this r... read more