Maggie McFly's | Middlebury

Daphne N. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

I can't believe how downhill this place has gone. For 10 employees to be walking around while dirty plates are left on tables, and food and old receipts remain all over the floor for over an hour is inexcusable. From the dirty glasses given with lipstick smeared on the rim, the remnants of nachos found on our table as we are eating (olives and chicken pieces), fruit flies flying all around us trying to get into my friend's overpriced "house Cabernet" at $11.25 (and it wasn't even Josh), let's just say I am embarrassed for ev... read more

Deane M. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

Can't begin to even describe the experience here. Horrible callous bartender probably one of the rudest I have ever encountered. We had originally planned to stay for dinner but had to leave. What is funny is I recommended this place to the group I was with as years back when I lived in the area I was here two nights a week. Now having moved back gotta find someplace else. Still reeling, still wondering what happened 

Pip H. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

I have multiple concerns about the décor of this establishment. Columns of granite at the entrance lead you to believe that this may be a five star restaurant, but then upon entering, you find a large tiki bar framed by two large palm trees. Cool? A surprise Polynesian motif. Not quite what I was expecting, but wait--are those Native North American totem poles serving as pillars to the balcony? There are canoe frames bolted to the ceiling alongside a WW1 fighter plane and a very old race car. A cherub chandelier allusive to... read more

Francis H. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

Not the best service. The menu is too big as it takes forever to flip through. The food is very over priced. I would say just to go for the drinks, but the last time I went the bar was dirty. Instead of cleaning it, the bartender just put napkins down. It's too bad because there really aren't too many options in the area, unless you go downtown. 

JC M. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

I ordered a cauliflower crust pizza. It was 18$ and what I got was a 9" inch tiny cold pizza (wasn't even kept war for us to pick up) and the crust wasn't even made with cauliflower. Disappointing. 

Danie C. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

Middlebury Conn. I really wanted to like this restaurant. It has great atmosphere but I was so disappointed in service and food. There was an unmanned hostess station when we arrived but we were happy to sit at the bar. My husband ordered a Budweiser and the bottle gushed out when bartender opened it/ cooler could be too cold. No big deal but it sprayed both of them. I ordered a margarita on the rocks. Surprised at small size of glass. We were ignored for a while but the bartender eventually came and took order- onion soup ... read more

Thomas S. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

Was there last night some what busy waited 25 min for a $12.50 martini that was room temperature in a snifter glass . Ordered the rib eye Oscar style and ended up with a NY strip that had a intense ammonia smell from the decomposing crab meat that was on top of a awful broken hollandaise sauce . To add my sautéed broccoli never came out . When I asked for a manger I got a eye roll from a overwhelmed server . Manager was very nice offered my a new steak ... but still got a NY strip instead of the ribeye and was terribly ... read more

Julie C. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

If I could give them less than 1 star I would. They have the worst customer service. We should have left them the guy who took our drink order said I'll get your drinks so you won't die of thirst. We patiently waited as several waitresses passed our table without even making eye contact. after 40 minutes we left cash on the table for drinks and walked out. NEVER TO RETURN. 

erica n. 

on Yelp

5 years ago

Went for my grandmas birthday with my mom and aunts. Didn't realize this could be worse than their Brookfield location! Server basically ignored us, 4 empty glasses, didn't see her until we were finished with our entrees, and had to ask for refills! My aunts pizza came out cold and we were half way done with our food before the manager even came out with the reheated pizza. My mom was then served COLD coffee! It certainly was not busy enough for us to be totally ignored. As a server I know what good service is about.....and ... read more