This profile has been claimed by the business owner or representative.
Barley Creek Brewing Company
- Restaurants
- Tannersville, PA
About this business
Location details
1774 Sullivan Trail, Tannersville, PA, 18372, United States
Get directions| Weekday | Schedule | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Mon | 11:00 a.m. to 9:30 p.m. | |
| Tue | 11:00 a.m. to 9:30 p.m. | |
| Wed | 11:00 a.m. to 9:30 p.m. | |
| Thu | 11:00 a.m. to 9:30 p.m. | |
| Fri | 11:00 a.m. to 10:30 p.m. | |
| Sat | 11:30 a.m. to 10:30 p.m. | |
| Sun | 11:30 a.m. to 9:30 p.m. |
The new menu has 1/2 what the old menu had. Choices are limited. The pizza is on a flatbread no longer round. Also limited choice as to toppings. The menu says 17"long. It's not , maybe it's 14". Salads which you previously had a large choice is minimal now. The chopped salad is gone. I've been coming here for years. I'll have to find a new place. I think they made a big mistake.
We eat here quite a lot since we live nearby. Expecting a decent lunch, Amd treating myself, I ordered the 1/2 rack of ribs. Never Again! The meat was SO DRY I couldn't chew it without drinking something. Also, the ribs were burned on the outsides and tuff to even bite into. Left overs? Been on the grill too long? Horrible. They should be ashamed to serve it.
To say I was disappointed is an understatement. I have never once written a review but then again I have never felt the need to. This place not only had bad food, not only had bad service, but I was also being eaten alive by bugs the entire time while sitting inside. When I received my appetizer after about 15 minutes, we had still not received our drinks or plates. When I ordered the veggie pasta as did someone else at my table, I informed the server of an allergy I had. When I received my food, I received a significantly s... read more
Business response:
Thanks for letting me know. That should not have happened. I am sorry and would like a second chance to make a first impression. We will certainly do better going forward.
Highly recommend the chicken tartar. Phenomenal 10/10. Ask for the extra side of salmonella it's delish
Service was good, food was subpar. My husband got the hot honey wings and they tasted like bbq. I got a regular burger and it didn't taste good at all. Had a corner piece of plastic in it like they cut it out of a package and heated it up. Didn't taste grilled or anything. I wouldn't recommend this place nor go back.
Business response:
Thanks Amy B for visiting Barley Creek and letting me know about your visit. I am sorry the experience we delivered to you was not mentioned to or "picked up" by your server. Had we known - we would have gotten a manager involved - figured out what happened (at that moment) and taken the necessary action to make the experience much better. Respectfully Trip R.
After waiting an eternity to be seated, I ordered the jalapeño cheddar sausage sandwich. The sausage was burnt and very small, little to no sauerkraut, it was awful. I hardly ever leave a review but I just had to this time. Big disappointment for $17.
Business response:
Obviously that’s not what we want to happen. That’s a new item on our menus custom made by our 1818 smokehouse team. Not sure the smokehouse team did enough training with the 1774 culinary team. This review just got forwarded to the GM’s FIX-IT NOW .. todo list. Thanks for letting me know. Respectfully Trip R
Been going here for years, but the last few times weren't very good. Today we decided to order through UberEats, and it was incredibly disappointing. We had two steaks that were very undercooked and chewy. It had No flavor, like... absolutely none. How do you mess up a steak that badly. The Nachos were stale. We were expecting them to be a little soggy after being delivered, but the dry parts were actually stale! The burger was badly underseasoned and (though this is personal preference) the bun was so dense you barely ... read more
Business response:
So many ways to respond. I’ll leave it at…thank you for your support over the years…We don’t have any control over Uber Eats. I am sorry for your experience. Happy to fix it but not if it involves a third party delivery company or a social media … impersonal (I don’t want to complain in person) review site.
Had high hopes for this one. I blame their management. We got sat and our waitress introduced herself. We ordered up drinks and apps. They were out of two of the apps. Drinks arrived quickly. Beer is good. Apps arrive a few minutes later and just thrown on the table by a food delivery person, not our waitress. Garlic knots burned on the bottom and served with a buttery raw garlick mess. Pretzel is old and impossible to eat from the show stopping swinging hoop. Waitress then returns... Out of three entrees. Order entrees a... read more
Business response:
Not what is supposed to happen - I would blame the owner for not holding the Managers more accountable for making sure the server training programs (servers) are more effective. Working on it and your review will help with that process. Thank you Seth.
Do not eat at this restaurant. I got a steak sandwich from there about a week ago and got severe food poisoning. I reached out to the restaurant and spoke to several managers with no resolution or help. I actually wound up in the emergency room because of it.
Business response:
Hello KM, We take food safety extremely seriously and adhere to, and exceed, all local and state health codes. In the 24 hours surrounding your visit, we served 113 cheesesteaks and have not received any similar reports from any other guest. Surely, if it was the meal you had with us, we would have been made aware. We are confident based upon our own food safety practices that it was not us, in addition to the lack of report from others. We are sorry to hear that you felt unwell but are confident that our establishment... read more
Frequently asked questions about Barley Creek Brewing Company
How is Barley Creek Brewing Company rated?
Barley Creek Brewing Company has a 4.3 star rating with 3,724 reviews.
When is Barley Creek Brewing Company open?
Barley Creek Brewing Company is open now. It will close at 10:30 p.m.