This profile has been claimed by the business owner or representative.
Theo's Italian
- Pizza
- Plainfield, IN
About this business
Location details
2498 Perry Crossing Way, Suite 105, Plainfield, IN, 46168, United States
Get directions
Food and service was awesome! Great cocktails. Everyone was very nice and friendly
Business response:
Thanks for the great review! So glad you had an awesome time, Cant wait to see you again!
Bread sticks were excellent. Chopped salad good but had clumps of blue cheese that were too big. Cheesecake was just ok. Crust nothing special. Linguine good.
Business response:
Thank you for the 4 stars and the feedback. Cant wait to see you again!
Our server was great very friendly and informative, very limited menu and prices were high I felt like food was good, hot & fresh however not something I would say I can’t wait to go back, nothing against the employees there and very clean just didn’t wow me.
Business response:
Thank you for your honest feedback. We are very sorry to hear that we didnt perform up to our high quality standards. We truly hope you will give us another opportunity to win you as a loyal guest.
Winna was such a delight! Food and service were everything I love about Cunningham restaurants.
Business response:
Thank you very much for your kind words. Cheers!
We went to Theo’s Italian doe the first time to celebrate a birthday. We were seated upstairs where it’s carpeted so the helped with the sound. Our waiter was a nice young man who was very knowledgeable about the dishes and was extremely attentive. Would definitely recommend!!
Business response:
Thank you very much for the great review. We truly appreciate it. Cheers!
The salads were excellent, as were the coctails and beer. Service was excellent, like most CRG restaurants. Decor nice. However, the entrees were anything but Italian (or good)...the Carbonara was fill with a ground meat, was excessively salty, and had what appeared to be mushrooms incorporated...NOT Carbonara. A beautiful classic Carbonara with egg/pecorino, your housemade pasta and pasta water would be such a delight...and no one in the Indy area is making it! Likewise, the foccacia bread tasted and had the consistency of ... read more
Business response:
Johnny thank you for your honest feedback. We continue to work with the Corporate Culinary team to review specs and tweak recipes to make every dish enticing for our guests. I have copied their team with your review so everyone is on the same page with what our guests are saying. We will continue to train and educate and work thru our growing pains. We truly hope you will give us another opportunity to serve you.
Theo’s has some tremendous menu items that demonstrate true Italian dishes. Their wine list is very minimal.
Salads were tasty, but kind of overpowering. Hard to taste flavor of anything afterwards. Burata was okay. Marguerita Pizza has good flavor, but mostly bread. One bite of cheese per slice was about it. More like breadsticks (just bread and sauce). Hubby liked his pasta/gnocchi dish, but again flavors kind of strong. He had a few bites and ate more of my dinner instead. The wrong sandwich was served to our friend, but she kept both and liked the meatball sandwich but much more enjoyed the Italian Sandwich she had ordered. If ... read more
Business response:
Thanks for the review Susan, We are sorry to hear the food didn't quite hit your expectations. Hopefully you will give us another chance to win you over on the next visit!
Food and drinks were very good! Would definitely go there again
Business response:
Thanks for the great review. Hope to see you again. Cheers!
Frequently asked questions about Theo's Italian
How is Theo's Italian rated?
Theo's Italian has a 4.3 star rating with 524 reviews.
When is Theo's Italian open?
Theo's Italian is permanently closed.