This profile has been claimed by the business owner or representative.
Theo's Italian
- Pizza
- Plainfield, IN
About this business
Location details
2498 Perry Crossing Way, Suite 105, Plainfield, IN, 46168, United States
Get directions
From the breadsticks to the pizza to the wine to the service All were outstanding
Business response:
Thanks for the great review. We look forward to serving you again. Cheers!
The Oct. visit was good, but the November 13, 2023 visit was amazing! We had a wonderful server both times, but this last visit the food was amazing and Jenna, our server rocked it. I wish I could remember the other servers name from our first visit, but they were all amazing and I will most definitely be returning.
Great service by Eli, food was great. Thought it strange that no bread was offered in an Italian location, but was tired and didn’t ask either. Appetizer; shrimp and calimari was okay. Ravioli and lobster wrapped in spinach were good but portion size was a bit smaller than expected. Overall good, I would consider going again.
Business response:
Thank you very much for your kind words. Eli is a very genuine person. We will celebrate him with the staff. Cheers!
Companions had the ziti which looked delicious and they enjoyed it. I split the lasagna pinsa with another companion. It was so-so. Two of us ordered the Italian Margarita. It had pineapple liqueur in it which supposedly made it sweeter. It was extremely sour. Our waiter removed it from our bill and replaced with a glass of wine.
Business response:
Thanks Linda for your review. We obviously didnt meet our high quality standards. We hope you will give us another chance to earn those 5 stars.
This was our first visit to Theo's and we really enjoyed it. The selection was good and included multiple vegetarian options.
Business response:
Anita Thank you very much for your review. We hope to earn your 5 stars on your next visit.
Flavor was good but sauce on my pasta was very watery. My husbands pizza was not cut and made it difficult to eat. Our server was amazing though.
Business response:
Susan, we thank you for your feedback! We apologize your items didnt meet your expectations, and we hope we get a chance to make things right with you. Please reach out to any member in management at 317-203-9107. Thank you!
We had the Meatball appetizer, which was delicious and the Shaved Brussels Sprout Ceasar Salad with Fried Shrimp. This Caesar Salad is amazing and is my husbands new favorite and go to salad at Theos.
Business response:
Thank you for your review and your 5 stars! Hope to see you again soon!
The food does not taste good. This is the second time we have tried this new restaurant. Cunningham Restaurant Group can do better.
Business response:
Im truly sorry that we did not stand up to our high quality standards. We will share your concerns amongst the team. Hope you will give us another chance to earn your 5 stars!
The server was great but the food was not. The carbonara was alfredo sauce with limp bacon and no pepper. The Fig Pig Goat could have used a lot more arugula.
Business response:
Im truly sorry that we did not stand up to our high quality standards. We will share your concerns amongst the team. Hope you will give us another chance to earn your 5 stars!
Frequently asked questions about Theo's Italian
How is Theo's Italian rated?
Theo's Italian has a 4.3 star rating with 524 reviews.
When is Theo's Italian open?
Theo's Italian is permanently closed.