Bethel Bakery | Bakeries at 5200 Brightwood Road - Bethel Park PA - Reviews - Photos - Phone Number

Bethel Bakery

1206 reviews
 5200 Brightwood Road, Bethel Park, PA 15102US

Write a review

Rating Error
Review Error
(412) 835-6658

Write a review

All reviews summary

1205 reviews
  • 438 reviews4.9
  • 283 reviews4.8
  • 184 reviews5.0
  • Show All
5on Wedding Wire, Aug 25, 2018
The tasting was great, love the presentation. more »
5on The Knot, Jul 18, 2018
Our wedding cake was DELICIOUS! Absolutely loved the orange seasonal cake flavor they had. Of course the almond batter with raspberry was amazing as well. They did a fantastic job on the design as well. If you have a summer wedding I highly recommend their orange cake. more »
5on Facebook, Jul 15, 2018
I purchased a cake for my friend via their website. I picked it up with no problems on a Saturday afternoon. It was a chocolate cake with chocolate mousse filling. It was phenomenal. Everyone really enjoyed it. I would highly recommend Bethel Bakery! more »
Business Response:
Thank you, Jessica! We are glad you enjoyed your cake! 😊
5on The Knot, Jul 11, 2018
Although I only got a bite on the day of the wedding (very sad) everyone said our cake was AMAZING!!! I can’t wait to eat the top part a year from now! The taste testing process was very simple and Bethel Bakery was amazing to work with! Thank you so much for creating the cake of my dreams! (Tired cake with almond batter and raspberry filling) more »
5on Facebook, Jul 09, 2018
Bethel bakery catered our cookie table at our wedding on 6/29/2018 and it was amazing! Everyone loved the huge assortment of cookies and it was a great wedding favor to send home with guests! Thanks again! more »
Business Response:
We are so glad you and your guests enjoyed them! Thank you for letting us be a part of your wedding!
5on Facebook, Jul 03, 2018
Excellent� more »
5on Facebook, Jul 03, 2018
Ordered cake for grad. Party in va......picked up on Wed. Packed in ice Thursday a m. Drove 5 hrs to v.a. Party on sunday.took out of refrigerator. Was great. Moist not old tasting. A+.... cookies lady lock just great too.🍰🍰 more »
Business Response:
We are so glad everything made the journey and it tasted great! Thank you for the kind review!
5on Facebook, Jul 01, 2018
Excellent as always! One of the best bakeries around. Though it did take a lot of self control on my half, to get the cupcakes to the destination, without eating a couple on the way! Thank-You, Bethel Bakery!!! more »
Business Response:
Thanks, Robin!!
5on Facebook, Jun 30, 2018
Family been going here since I can remember, just picked my birthday cake up yesterday and next month will be getting my sons! Excuse me while I go eat a donut 😂😂😂 I'm gonna miss yinz when we move next summer! more »
Business Response:
Thank you, Melissa! We are sad to see you move from the Burgh but would love to see you when you visit!!
5on The Knot, Jun 26, 2018
Best cake ever!!! We had the almond torte with vanilla bean and raspberry filling! It was grrreeeeeaaaaat everyone loved my cake more »
5on The Knot, Jun 25, 2018
The best wedding cake I could have ever asked for! We went to taste the cake several months ago with my Aunt and Uncle and we were walked through all of the different flavor options, as well as size, colors, decorations. Every option was so beautiful and delicious, but what we went with was ultimately delivered and turned out way better than we could have expected. When my now husband and I saw the cake on the cake table during our reception, we knew we had made the right decision. We were so excited to be able to cut into it and take a bite! We had guests continuously come up to us and compliment us on our cake and we continuously shouted BETHEL BAKERY!!!! I grew up eating Bethel Bakery cakes, so I wouldn’t have gone anywhere else regardless, however, my now husband and his family had no clue how amazing it truly was and I am so glad this was the decision we went with. Thank you to the entire baking team, the staff that assisted us with the decision making process, and the delivery driver, for getting the cake to the venue with no issues at all (at least not that I know of, LOL). more »
5on The Knot, Jun 22, 2018
We were so thankful to have Bethel Bakery on our wedding team! The wedding team manager Katlyn is brilliant and so easy to get along with. We were planning the wedding from out of town, but they were great at communication and were able to schedule the trials on weekends when we were home. We got a combination of a wedding cake and cookies for the cookie table. They delivered everything on time and in easy to transport containers. Everything tasted amazing!!! People are still talking about the dessert tables. Would recommend to anyone without any reservations! more »
5on Trip Advisor, Jun 18, 2018
Unique cakes, wonderful donuts, especially the buttercream filled ones,, Hometown bakeries are few and far between, its worth the trip and the wait....
more »
5on Trip Advisor, Jun 18, 2018
Sheet cake
Delicious, wonderful service, great decorating. Always a joy to stop by and geab some cupcakes or scrumptious bakeries
more »
5on Facebook, Jun 13, 2018
I wanted a speciality cake. I called aroind and was told nobody would make it because of what was on it. I'm so glad I choose Bethel Bakery. I want to say thank you so much to the wonderful staff and Miss Carol for helping me with my order. Miss Carol had wonderful ideas to add and very plesant to work with. They did a fantastic job and my presentation on drug awareness was a success. Thank you again. I would recommend you to everyone and anyone. more »
5on The Knot, Jun 11, 2018
If you want a cake that not only looks beautiful but tastes amazing, go to Bethel Bakery! The icing is so delicious, not over the top sugary. I requested a fun-fetti cake and they did not disappoint! We had a special cake which looked like a tree trunk to fit with our rustic theme, and we provided silk flowers which they added to the cake. It was gorgeous, and it was the perfect addition to our reception! more »
5on Facebook, Jun 06, 2018
We just picked up my daughter’s birthday cake. I can’t even say how absolutely gorgeous it is. You guys did an amazing job � more »
Business Response:
We are so glad you were happy with your cake!!
5on Facebook, Jun 04, 2018
They did an amazing job for my babyshower cake so I thought it would only be perfect for them to do my daughter's first birthday cake and of course it turned out amazing!! more »
Business Response:
Thanks, Dana! We are glad you enjoyed your cake!!
5on Facebook, Jun 03, 2018
Yet again another successful event with a cake everyone raved about! Thank you Bethel for always suppling the most perfectly delicious treats! more »
Business Response:
Thanks, Sara! We are glad you enjoyed your cake!
5on Facebook, Jun 02, 2018
Wedding cake was beautiful and delicious thank you all so much. October 2017 more »
Business Response:
Thank you, Chrissy! It was a pleasure making you your wedding cake!!
5on Facebook, May 31, 2018
We can always count on Bethel Bakery for standout decorations on special occasion cakes that taste terrific! Always friendly service! Thanks! more »
Business Response:
Thank you for the kind review, Michelle!!
5on Facebook, May 31, 2018
Best bakery in the state!!! more »
Business Response:
Thanks, Janice!
5on The Knot, May 27, 2018
Our cake was SO DELICIOUS and decorated exactly as we envisioned it - simply to accentuate the fresh florals and our custom cake topper. We also ordered cookies to supplement our cookie table and they're just so good, they can't be beat. Thank you, Bethel Bakery! more »
5on The Knot, May 24, 2018
Thank you, Bethel Bakery! We had three different kinds of cupcakes for our wedding, and not only did the look gorgeous, they tasted amazing and were a huge crowd pleaser. We scheduled our tasting fairly early on in the process, and the staff were very accommodating when we needed to come in again to make final frosting color choices. Thank you! more »
5on BirdEye, May 07, 2018
Mother's Day Cakes more »
Page 1 of 37

Google reviews summary

283 reviews


5200 Brightwood Road, Bethel Park, PA 15102
Today 7:00 am - 7:00 pm


Since Bethel Bakery opened for business in the 1955 in the south hills section of Pittsburgh, generations of patrons have made their way to the shop for the bakery’s signature pastries, cookies, coffeecakes and one-of-a-kind cakes.

With a number of years of bakery experience, a stint in the Navy behind him and a small inheritance, Morris Walsh, with characteristic determination, made his dream of owning his own bakery a reality when he and a partner opened for business during the Eisenhower administration. While his business partner left the venture within a few months, Morris soon gained another associate, his future wife, Anna.

Together, the couple built the boutique bakery into one of the busiest and most beloved purveyors of high-quality baked goods in western Pennsylvania. And they did it while raising seven children, all of whom would eventually work in the family business.

Today, a second generation of the Walsh family manages the bakery. John and his wife, Chris, took over day-to-day operations in 1991and expanded the already extensive inventory of baked goods, but Morris and Anna’s legacy of exceptional quality and customer service lives on.

People travel for miles for a taste of Bethel Bakery’s signature buttercream icing and discriminating brides across the region wouldn’t dream of celebrating their nuptials with anything but a hand-crafted, custom-designed Bethel Bakery cake decorated by one of the shop’s talented designers.

In 2006, Bethel Bakery’s iconic status in the region was recognized by award-winning documentary filmmaker Rick Sebak, who featured the bakery in his WQED program, “What Makes Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh.”

In an era driven by convenience and competition from mega-markets and chain stores, Bethel Bakery has endured because it is far more than just a retailer of baked goods—it is an memorable destination experience and a nostalgic reminder of the charms of independent bakeries that were once part of the fabric of every community.
more »