Bethel Bakery
5200 Brightwood Road, Bethel Park, PA 15102
Closed now
About
Since Bethel Bakery opened for business in the 1955 in the south hills section of Pittsburgh, generations of patrons have made their way to the shop for the bakery’s signature pastries, cookies, coffeecakes and one-of-a-kind cakes. With a number of years of bakery experience, a stint in the Navy behind him and a small inheritance, Morris Walsh, with characteristic determination, made his dream of owning his own bakery a reality when he and a partner opened for business during the Eisenhower administration. While his business partner left the venture within a few months, Morris soon gained another associate, his future wife, Anna. Together, the couple built the boutique bakery into one of
- 459 Reviews4.9Facebook
- 350 Reviews4.8Google
- 198 Reviews4.9The Knot
- Show All
Sort By:
3 results available.
Newest
Stacie Fisher Rocco on Facebook
14 days ago
11/07/2018, 12:11 PM
Loved my wedding cake! thank you!
Business Response:
What a great picture! Thank you for sharing it with us. We are so happy you enjoyed your wedding cake!
Loved my wedding cake! thank you!
Beachgoer53 on Trip Advisor
14 days ago
11/07/2018, 00:11 AM
Bethel Bakery- Yum!
This Bakery has the most delicious and beautiful cakes. The pastry is amazing! You can pick a variety of baked goods and breads. They have gluten-free options too!
This Bakery has the most delicious and beautiful cakes. The pastry is amazing! You can pick a variety of baked goods and breads. They have gluten-free options too!
Bethel Bakery- Yum!
This Bakery has the most delicious and beautiful cakes. The pastry is amazing! You can pick a variety of baked goods and breads. They have gluten-free options too!
Janna R on The Knot
17 days ago
11/04/2018, 01:11 AM
So easy to work with, and they were able to recreate my “Pinterest dream wedding cake.” Thanks so much for adding to our special day!
So easy to work with, and they were able to recreate my “Pinterest dream wedding cake.” Thanks so much for adding to our special day!
Cheryl Hilty on Facebook
18 days ago
11/03/2018, 12:11 PM
Had them make a special cake and they nailed it!! Could not be any happier with the out come. Thank you so much
Business Response:
Hi. Cheryl! We are so glad you enjoyed your cake!!
Had them make a special cake and they nailed it!! Could not be any happier with the out come. Thank you so much
Tabitha S on The Knot
18 days ago
11/03/2018, 03:11 AM
Throughout the entire cake process Bethel Bakery was so helpful! The tasting was very informative and they helped my surprisingly very opinionated father, opinionated husband, and I to agree on a design choice that turned out beautifully. The colors on the cake matched the wedding colors perfectly. We made decisions with them well in advance and they made sure that I didn't even have to think about the cake on the day of the wedding until it was time to cut it. The cake was so delicious and enjoyed by all! They also were able to coordinate with Gluuteny to make sure that the vegan desserts were delivered to the venue. It helped take away another thing to think about! They were very on top of... more>>
Throughout the entire cake process Bethel Bakery was so helpful! The tasting was very informative and they helped my surprisingly very opinionated father, opinionated husband, and I to agree on a design choice that turned out beautifully. The colors on the cake matched the wedding colors perfectly. We made decisions with them well in advance and they made sure that I didn't even have to think about the cake on the day of the wedding until it was time to cut it. The cake was so delicious and enjoyed by all! They also were able to coordinate with Gluuteny to make sure that the vegan desserts were delivered to the venue. It helped take away another thing to think about! They were very on top of everything and we in touch throughout the process. Helpful staff, delicious and beautiful cake work.
lindsay0215 on Trip Advisor
23 days ago
10/29/2018, 10:10 AM
Excellent!!
We love Bethel Bakery! Can’t go wrong with their awesome cookie assortment. Years ago we ordered our wedding cake here- it was perfect!
We love Bethel Bakery! Can’t go wrong with their awesome cookie assortment. Years ago we ordered our wedding cake here- it was perfect!
Excellent!!
We love Bethel Bakery! Can’t go wrong with their awesome cookie assortment. Years ago we ordered our wedding cake here- it was perfect!
Heidi K on Trip Advisor
23 days ago
10/29/2018, 01:10 AM
Reliable and delicious!
Bethel Bakery is a quality bakery. They have a large variety of cake batter flavors and icings. I can't give them 5 stars because they do use some artificial flavors and colors.Their staff is friendly and competent.
Bethel Bakery is a quality bakery. They have a large variety of cake batter flavors and icings. I can't give them 5 stars because they do use some artificial flavors and colors.Their staff is friendly and competent.
Reliable and delicious!
Bethel Bakery is a quality bakery. They have a large variety of cake batter flavors and icings. I can't give them 5 stars because they do use some artificial flavors and colors.Their staff is friendly and competent.
Lacie Ring on Facebook
a month ago
10/26/2018, 05:10 AM
Thank you to Bethel Bakery for making our custom cake for our Gender Reveal Party! It was the talk of the night. It was beautifully decorated as we requested, including the pink batter, and it tasted amazing. Thank you again for being a big part of our special day!
Business Response:
We are so glad your enjoyed your cake! Congratulations on your baby girl!
Thank you to Bethel Bakery for making our custom cake for our Gender Reveal Party! It was the talk of the night. It was beautifully decorated as we requested, including the pink batter, and it tasted amazing. Thank you again for being a big part of our special day!
Megan E on The Knot
a month ago
10/26/2018, 04:10 AM
Bethel bakery made the selection of a wedding cake incredibly easy and fun. Our tasting was very informative and we were able to try all kinds of combinations to make sure we chose the best flavors for us. The design team also took a picture I found online and made a really close recreation with changes specific to our wedding's style. Overall, the cake looked great and tasted fantastic!
Bethel bakery made the selection of a wedding cake incredibly easy and fun. Our tasting was very informative and we were able to try all kinds of combinations to make sure we chose the best flavors for us. The design team also took a picture I found online and made a really close recreation with changes specific to our wedding's style. Overall, the cake looked great and tasted fantastic!