Bethel Bakery

Name: Bethel Bakery
Address: 5200 Brightwood Road, Bethel Park, PA, 15102, US
Telephone: (412) 835-6658
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.9

4.9

★★

2107 reviews

|Restaurants|Bethel Park, PA 15102 United States

5200 Brightwood Road, Bethel Park, PA 15102 United States

(412) 835-6658

https://bethelbakery.com/

Bakeries, Desserts, Food

Open now:7:00 am - 6:00 pm

About

Since Bethel Bakery opened for business in 1955 in the south hills section of Pittsburgh, generations of patrons have made their way to the shop for the bakery’s signature pastries, cookies, coffeecakes and one-of-a-kind cakes. With a number of years of bakery experience, a stint in the Navy behind him and a small inheritance, Morris Walsh, with characteristic determination, made his dream of owning his own bakery a reality when he and a partner opened for business during the Eisenhower administration. While his business partner left the venture within a few months, Morris soon gained another associate, his future wife, Anna. Together, the couple built the boutique bakery into one of the

BIRDEYE FOR BUSINESSES

This profile is powered by Birdeye. Over 90,000 businesses use Birdeye everyday to get more reviews and manage all customer feedback. Birdeye helps millions of local businesses to be found online with all their reviews and accurate business information. Learn more about Birdeye

4.9

★★

2,107 reviews

5★1,751

4★178

3★55

2★1

1★0

122 reviews have no rating

Reviews(1206)

Google Reviews(901)

Sort By:

Featured

Rebecca W. on Birdeye

★★

3 days ago

Bethel Bakery made an AMAZING custom Winnie the Pooh bear cake for my son’s first birthday party! I shared a few inspiration pictures with Carol who was so patient and thorough as we discussed every single detail. She was very focused on making sure I got exactly what I wanted- even when I didn’t have a crystal clear idea of exactly what I wanted at first! Their decorator Charlene brought my vision to life and then some- absolutely perfect and I could not be more pleased! My family has used Bethel Bakery for many occasions over the years- always delicious, but this was my first experience with ordering a cake that involved significant custom work. Would definitely order a custom cake from them again and hope that they continue to offer custom work in the years to come.

Business Response:

Thank you so much for your review, Rebecca. We are so happy to hear that your cake was a success. We all loved that cake as well when we saw it completely and are so pleased that you felt the same! We love to make your creations come to life and be a part of your special day. We welcome you back any time for another custom cake. :) Sweet regards, Bethel Bakery

Katie Vecchi on The Knot

★★

19 days ago

We reached out to Bethel Bakery with a little bit of a unique idea for our cake (black exterior with a white geode). Not only were they able to understand our idea - they brought it to life so well. Everyone loved the flavors of the cake too - and we had two different ones for our guests to pick from.

Nicole Bronson on The Knot

★★

a month ago

Absolutely amazing wedding cake! Cake had incredible flavors and was very moist. Also delivered on the exact design I was hoping for!

Elizabeth Davidson on The Knot

★★

2 months ago

We did cupcakes and a small two tier cake for our wedding - all were beautiful and set up nicely! We heard rave reviews for the flavors!

Sarah on Wedding Wire

★★

2 months ago

We had a seamless experience working with Bethel Bakery for our wedding cake. At the beginning, we weren’t sure what design we wanted, and so they spent a lot of time with us and were so patient and helped us pick out the perfect cake. They did an amazing job with the design, and it was beautiful. Wedding cake isn’t usually good, but Bethel cakes are GOOD! We chose chocolate cake with a raspberry buttercream + European raspberry fillings and all of our guests raved about how good it was! We can’t wait for another excuse to eat another Bethel Bakery cake!

Ashley F on The Knot

★★

2 months ago

Bethel Bakery made my cake for around 150 people. We were able to sample and walk thru all the different options they had so we knew exactly what we wanted and what to expect. While I was so busy that I did not get to eat any cake on my wedding day. The cake was beautiful and arrived on time for our florist to decorate it. My guests said the cake flavors were amazing and the cake was very fresh. While sometimes they are hard to get ahold of because they are so busy the Bethel Bakery team does a great job!

Bridget Keefe on The Knot

★★

2 months ago

Bethel Bakery made us the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake! The taste testing process was so much fun and at our consultation, Amanda was so great with providing recommendations and insight based on her experiences with other customers. They absolutely nailed our vision for the cake and all of our guests couldn’t get over how good it tasted. They are a staple bakery in the Pittsburgh area for a reason, so don’t hesitate to hire them as your wedding cake bakery!

Emma P. on Wedding Wire

★★

2 months ago

My husband and I absolutely loved our cake. I normally can't stand wedding cake! We were able to do our cake tasting in our home (cup cakes) which meant we could discuss without feeling rushed, and we were able to include one of our closest friends for another opinion! It was super fun and memorable! They created a perfect cake! It was simple and beautiful, like something out of a magazine. All of our guests loved it! I couldn't have asked for anything more!

Business Response:

Bethel Bakery's reply: Hello Emma, and thank you so much for your kind words and review. We're thrilled to hear that your cake was delicious and beautiful for your special day. We can't wait to be a small, sweet part of all the celebrations to come in your new life together. Congratulations! Sweet regards, Bethel Bakery

Cassie Ruby-Nemec on The Knot

★★

3 months ago

Our wedding cake was a 4 tier and it was absolutely gorgeous. Even better than I had imagined! Plus it was delicious as always with BB cakes.