Bethel Bakery

4.9

★★

1397 reviews

|Restaurants|Bethel Park, PA 15102

5200 Brightwood Road, Bethel Park, PA 15102

(412) 835-6658

http://www.bethelbakery.com

Bakeries, Desserts, Food

Closed now

About

Since Bethel Bakery opened for business in the 1955 in the south hills section of Pittsburgh, generations of patrons have made their way to the shop for the bakery’s signature pastries, cookies, coffeecakes and one-of-a-kind cakes. With a number of years of bakery experience, a stint in the Navy behind him and a small inheritance, Morris Walsh, with characteristic determination, made his dream of owning his own bakery a reality when he and a partner opened for business during the Eisenhower administration. While his business partner left the venture within a few months, Morris soon gained another associate, his future wife, Anna. Together, the couple built the boutique bakery into one of

BIRDEYE FOR BUSINESSES

This profile is powered by BirdEye. Over 50,000 businesses use BirdEye everyday to get more reviews and manage all customer feedback. BirdEye helps millions of local businesses to be found online with all their reviews and accurate business information. Learn more about BirdEye

4.9

★★

1,397 reviews

5★1,223

4★125

3★27

2★0

1★0

22 reviews have no rating

467 Reviews4.9Facebook
406 Reviews4.8Google
204 Reviews4.9The Knot
Show All

Write a review

Reviews(991)

Google Reviews(406)

Sort By:

5 results available.

Recommended

Tara Louttit-Fine on Facebook

8 days ago

Bethel Bakery is the best!!! They did an awesome job on my daughter's 11th Birthday cake!!! Love them!!!

Business Response:

Thank you, Tara! We are so glad you and Megan enjoyed the cake!

Sydney S on The Knot

★★

12 days ago

We booked Bethel Bakery for the cake at our wedding in Fall 2018. Their consultation process is very professional, yet super comfortable. They have a great selection of samples to ensure that you create the wedding cake of your dreams. Their prices were very reasonable, and their cake speaks for itself. We were able to get even more than we anticipated within our budget.
Bethel Bakery confirmed all the details for the cake delivery ahead of the wedding, and ensured not to bother us the day-of. We were delighted to see how gorgeous and delicious cake turned out. Our guests gave many compliments on both appearance and taste.
Bethel Bakery is the best option for your wedding cake.

Katie Wiltrout on Facebook

13 days ago

Thank you Bethel Bakery for the last minute but amazing cake and cupcakes for my daughters fourth birthday! They were delicious and beautiful!!

Business Response:

You’re welcome! We are so glad you and Quinn enjoyed it! Her tutu matched perfectly!

Kellyswife2 on Trip Advisor

★★

18 days ago

Good bakery
Love almost everything they make. Not big on the cake icing. Either you love it or you don’t, but, everything else they have is so good. A must stop

Cassandra Gerle on Facebook

20 days ago

Bethel Bakery did such a wonderful job on my daughters 1st birthday cake. It was the snow rose cake and it was both beautiful and delicious. It was one of the best cakes I've ever had and could not have been happier! They were also extremely helpful and professional over the phone and made sure we knew exactly what the cake would look like while their site was down. Thank you Bethel bakery for making sure the cake was perfect for our event!

Business Response:

Cassandra, we are so glad you enjoyed your cake! We hope Kaylee had a great first birthday!!

Steven Adams on Facebook

a month ago

Absolutely one of the top bakeries around, if not the best. Thank you so much for creating the perfect Pineapple shaped cake for my wife's suprise bday party, not only did it look awesome but the flavors were just as great! Everyone was super impressed and wanted to know where it was from, esp after tasting it. I put an inquiry in online and they got right back to me and we set up a phone appointment and went over all the details and they were able to answer all questions. Great experience in every aspect, looks like more cakes to come in the future from here!!
Thanks to everyone at Bethel who was part of making this cake the center piece of the party!!

Business Response:

Steven, we are so glad you and your wife enjoyed her cake! Thank you for the kind recommendation and we look forward to helping you celebrate in the future! 🎂☺️

Gretchen C on The Knot

★★

a month ago

Bethel Bakery was BEYOND helpful when it came to deciding on our cake!! They keep full and detailed notes each time you call so that no matter who you are speaking with, they know what is going on! They were more than willing to answer any questions I had and helped me combine 3 of my inspiration cakes into one amazing creation! The fact that they could do this with buttercream only and no fondant want awesome!
Everyone at the wedding loved the look and taste. Lots of soon to be brides specifically mentioned that they would be contacting Bethel after they saw my creation :)

Business Response:

Hi Gretchen! It was a pleasure working with you to create your wedding cake and we are so happy you and your guests loved it! We wish you both so much happiness and are looking forward to working with you in the future. Sweet Regards, Katlyn

Meaghan S on The Knot

★★

a month ago

The cake was amazing and they were very easy to work with! We got a ton of compliments on the mango filling!

Niki George on Facebook

a month ago

We ordered our wedding cake from Bethel Bakery and it was beautiful. Granted, I didn’t get to eat my cake the day of my wedding, the cake was just as good at our one year wedding anniversary.

Business Response:

Oh no! No wedding cake on your wedding day!?! It sounds like enjoying your top tier made your 1st anniversary that much sweeter! We wish you many more sweet anniversaries and are honored to be a part of both days!